{"publication":{"title":"Accounting and ERP Software in Finland","summary":"","slug":"accounting-and-erp-software-finland","edition":1,"published_at":"2026-11-12T15:54:04.835Z","url":"https://www.bot.spot/research/accounting-and-erp-software-finland","license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","publisher":"bot.spot (Botdot Oy)"},"document":{"kind":"industry","rank":{"of":80,"position":null},"audit":{"panels":[{"id":"discovery","lines":[],"counts":{"issue":0,"passed":0,"review":0,"not_measured":0},"reason":"Discovery checks could not run","status":"not_measured","flagged":[],"check_ids":[]},{"id":"seo","lines":[],"counts":{"issue":0,"passed":0,"review":0,"not_measured":0},"reason":"SEO checks could not run","status":"not_measured","flagged":[],"check_ids":[]},{"id":"performance","lines":[],"counts":{"issue":0,"passed":0,"review":0,"not_measured":0},"reason":"Lab test did not run","status":"not_measured","flagged":[],"check_ids":[]},{"id":"agentic","lines":[{"label":"llms.txt","value":"Couldn't check","status":"info","check_id":"llms_txt.present"}],"counts":{"issue":0,"passed":0,"review":0,"not_measured":0},"reason":"Interaction checks were not measured","status":"not_measured","flagged":[],"check_ids":[]}],"status":"skipped","platform":null,"site_facts":null,"robots_found":false,"llms_txt_found":false,"sitemap_url_count":0,"sitemap_url_count_capped":false},"brand":null,"scope":{"status":"partial","failed_runs":25,"completed_runs":115,"requested_runs":140,"engines_measured":["chatgpt","google_ai_overviews","google_ai_mode","gemini","copilot","claude"],"contributing_prompts":20,"engines_not_measured":["perplexity"]},"engines":[{"engine":"chatgpt","metrics":{"visibility":{"delta":null,"prior":null,"current":0},"owned_citation":{"delta":null,"prior":null,"current":0},"share_of_voice":{"delta":null,"prior":null,"current":0}},"has_data":true,"included":true,"completed_answers":20,"prior_completed_answers":0},{"engine":"google_ai_overviews","metrics":{"visibility":{"delta":null,"prior":null,"current":0},"owned_citation":{"delta":null,"prior":null,"current":0},"share_of_voice":{"delta":null,"prior":null,"current":0}},"has_data":true,"included":true,"completed_answers":18,"prior_completed_answers":0},{"engine":"google_ai_mode","metrics":{"visibility":{"delta":null,"prior":null,"current":0},"owned_citation":{"delta":null,"prior":null,"current":0},"share_of_voice":{"delta":null,"prior":null,"current":0}},"has_data":true,"included":true,"completed_answers":19,"prior_completed_answers":0},{"engine":"gemini","metrics":{"visibility":{"delta":null,"prior":null,"current":0},"owned_citation":{"delta":null,"prior":null,"current":0},"share_of_voice":{"delta":null,"prior":null,"current":0}},"has_data":true,"included":true,"completed_answers":18,"prior_completed_answers":0},{"engine":"perplexity","metrics":{"visibility":{"delta":null,"prior":null,"current":null},"owned_citation":{"delta":null,"prior":null,"current":null},"share_of_voice":{"delta":null,"prior":null,"current":null}},"has_data":false,"included":true,"completed_answers":0,"prior_completed_answers":0},{"engine":"copilot","metrics":{"visibility":{"delta":null,"prior":null,"current":0},"owned_citation":{"delta":null,"prior":null,"current":0},"share_of_voice":{"delta":null,"prior":null,"current":0}},"has_data":true,"included":true,"completed_answers":20,"prior_completed_answers":0},{"engine":"claude","metrics":{"visibility":{"delta":null,"prior":null,"current":0},"owned_citation":{"delta":null,"prior":null,"current":0},"share_of_voice":{"delta":null,"prior":null,"current":0}},"has_data":true,"included":true,"completed_answers":20,"prior_completed_answers":0}],"lineage":{"origin":"build","edition":1,"series_id":"270a629c-709a-493e-9d20-2c00f8f13c37","source_edition":null,"source_engines":[],"compared_engines":[],"source_report_id":null,"source_generated_at":null},"request":{"engines":["chatgpt","google_ai_overviews","google_ai_mode","gemini","perplexity","copilot","claude"],"persona_count":4,"prompts_per_persona":5},"summary":{"visibility":{"delta":null,"prior":null,"current":0,"prior_numerator":null,"current_numerator":0,"prior_denominator":null,"current_denominator":115},"avg_position":{"delta":null,"prior":null,"current":null,"prior_numerator":null,"current_numerator":null,"prior_denominator":null,"current_denominator":0},"owned_citation":{"delta":null,"prior":null,"current":0,"prior_numerator":null,"current_numerator":0,"prior_denominator":null,"current_denominator":115},"share_of_voice":{"delta":null,"prior":null,"current":0,"prior_numerator":null,"current_numerator":0,"prior_denominator":null,"current_denominator":566}},"industry":{"name":"Accounting and ERP software","focus":null,"scope":"Companies that develop and provide software applications, SaaS platforms, and systems for accounting, electronic financial administration, and enterprise resource planning (ERP) in Finland.","market":"FI","language":"fi","segments":["Cloud financial management and accounting platforms","SME enterprise resource planning (ERP) software","Micro-business and solo entrepreneur invoicing and bookkeeping tools","Industry-specific ERP systems (manufacturing, wholesale, construction)","Enterprise ERP and international challenger platforms"],"requested":"Accounting and ERP Software","description":"Software platforms and cloud-based applications for electronic financial management, bookkeeping, statutory accounting, and enterprise resource planning (ERP) tailored to Finnish regulatory requirements, corporate banking systems, and industry-specific business processes."},"personas":[{"id":"0a10f26a-16cb-43a4-b930-3477c3446bb5","title":"Finnish micro-entrepreneurs and sole traders","market":"FI","prompts":[{"id":"b3968161-680a-496a-8f85-64b5fdf89ab9","leader":{"is_self":false,"apex_domain":"procountor.fi","canonical_name":"Procountor Solo"},"engines":["chatgpt","google_ai_overviews","google_ai_mode","gemini","perplexity","copilot","claude"],"outcomes":[{"rank":null,"engine":"chatgpt","status":"absent","evidence_ref":"b3968161-680a-496a-8f85-64b5fdf89ab9:chatgpt"},{"rank":null,"engine":"google_ai_overviews","status":"absent","evidence_ref":"b3968161-680a-496a-8f85-64b5fdf89ab9:google_ai_overviews"},{"rank":null,"engine":"google_ai_mode","status":"absent","evidence_ref":"b3968161-680a-496a-8f85-64b5fdf89ab9:google_ai_mode"},{"rank":null,"engine":"gemini","status":"absent","evidence_ref":"b3968161-680a-496a-8f85-64b5fdf89ab9:gemini"},{"rank":null,"engine":"perplexity","status":"failed","evidence_ref":null},{"rank":null,"engine":"copilot","status":"absent","evidence_ref":"b3968161-680a-496a-8f85-64b5fdf89ab9:copilot"},{"rank":null,"engine":"claude","status":"absent","evidence_ref":"b3968161-680a-496a-8f85-64b5fdf89ab9:claude"}],"prompt_text":"Mikä on paras sähköinen laskutus- ja kirjanpito-ohjelma toiminimiyrittäjälle?","prompt_type":"direct","share_of_voice":0,"companies_named":12,"visibility_rate":0,"consensus_answer":null,"consensus_claims":[],"completed_answers":6,"owned_citation_rate":0},{"id":"885b1423-6fea-4cb9-9113-340045ec37ab","leader":{"is_self":false,"apex_domain":"holvi.com","canonical_name":"Holvi"},"engines":["chatgpt","google_ai_overviews","google_ai_mode","gemini","perplexity","copilot","claude"],"outcomes":[{"rank":null,"engine":"chatgpt","status":"absent","evidence_ref":"885b1423-6fea-4cb9-9113-340045ec37ab:chatgpt"},{"rank":null,"engine":"google_ai_overviews","status":"absent","evidence_ref":"885b1423-6fea-4cb9-9113-340045ec37ab:google_ai_overviews"},{"rank":null,"engine":"google_ai_mode","status":"absent","evidence_ref":"885b1423-6fea-4cb9-9113-340045ec37ab:google_ai_mode"},{"rank":null,"engine":"gemini","status":"absent","evidence_ref":"885b1423-6fea-4cb9-9113-340045ec37ab:gemini"},{"rank":null,"engine":"perplexity","status":"failed","evidence_ref":null},{"rank":null,"engine":"copilot","status":"absent","evidence_ref":"885b1423-6fea-4cb9-9113-340045ec37ab:copilot"},{"rank":null,"engine":"claude","status":"absent","evidence_ref":"885b1423-6fea-4cb9-9113-340045ec37ab:claude"}],"prompt_text":"Mitä eri vaihtoehtoja suomalaisella pienyrityksellä on sähköisen taloushallinnon hoitamiseen ja mitä ne tyypillisesti maksavat kuukaudessa?","prompt_type":"discovery","share_of_voice":0,"companies_named":20,"visibility_rate":0,"consensus_answer":"Pienyrityksen sähköisen taloushallinnon kulut riippuvat työnjaosta ja tositteista vaihdellen tyypillisesti 0–400 euroon kuukaudessa ilman arvonlisäveroa. Yrittäjän itse hoitama kevyt laskutus tai kirjanpito-ohjelmisto maksaa usein noin 0–30 euroa kuukaudessa. Ohjelmiston ja tilitoimiston yhdistävä yhteiskäyttömalli maksaa pienyritykselle yleensä noin 80–350 euroa kuukaudessa.","consensus_claims":[{"text":"Pienyrityksen sähköisen taloushallinnon kulut riippuvat työnjaosta ja tositteista vaihdellen tyypillisesti 0–400 euroon kuukaudessa ilman arvonlisäveroa.","sources":[{"engine":"google_ai_overviews","evidence_ref":"885b1423-6fea-4cb9-9113-340045ec37ab:google_ai_overviews"},{"engine":"google_ai_mode","evidence_ref":"885b1423-6fea-4cb9-9113-340045ec37ab:google_ai_mode"},{"engine":"copilot","evidence_ref":"885b1423-6fea-4cb9-9113-340045ec37ab:copilot"}]},{"text":"Yrittäjän itse hoitama kevyt laskutus tai kirjanpito-ohjelmisto maksaa usein noin 0–30 euroa kuukaudessa.","sources":[{"engine":"chatgpt","evidence_ref":"885b1423-6fea-4cb9-9113-340045ec37ab:chatgpt"},{"engine":"google_ai_mode","evidence_ref":"885b1423-6fea-4cb9-9113-340045ec37ab:google_ai_mode"},{"engine":"claude","evidence_ref":"885b1423-6fea-4cb9-9113-340045ec37ab:claude"}]},{"text":"Ohjelmiston ja tilitoimiston yhdistävä yhteiskäyttömalli maksaa pienyritykselle yleensä noin 80–350 euroa kuukaudessa.","sources":[{"engine":"chatgpt","evidence_ref":"885b1423-6fea-4cb9-9113-340045ec37ab:chatgpt"},{"engine":"google_ai_mode","evidence_ref":"885b1423-6fea-4cb9-9113-340045ec37ab:google_ai_mode"},{"engine":"copilot","evidence_ref":"885b1423-6fea-4cb9-9113-340045ec37ab:copilot"}]}],"completed_answers":6,"owned_citation_rate":0},{"id":"976fc6f6-01d6-4101-880a-031e8301cbac","leader":{"is_self":false,"apex_domain":"procountor.fi","canonical_name":"Procountor Solo"},"engines":["chatgpt","google_ai_overviews","google_ai_mode","gemini","perplexity","copilot","claude"],"outcomes":[{"rank":null,"engine":"chatgpt","status":"absent","evidence_ref":"976fc6f6-01d6-4101-880a-031e8301cbac:chatgpt"},{"rank":null,"engine":"google_ai_overviews","status":"absent","evidence_ref":"976fc6f6-01d6-4101-880a-031e8301cbac:google_ai_overviews"},{"rank":null,"engine":"google_ai_mode","status":"absent","evidence_ref":"976fc6f6-01d6-4101-880a-031e8301cbac:google_ai_mode"},{"rank":null,"engine":"gemini","status":"absent","evidence_ref":"976fc6f6-01d6-4101-880a-031e8301cbac:gemini"},{"rank":null,"engine":"perplexity","status":"failed","evidence_ref":null},{"rank":null,"engine":"copilot","status":"absent","evidence_ref":"976fc6f6-01d6-4101-880a-031e8301cbac:copilot"},{"rank":null,"engine":"claude","status":"absent","evidence_ref":"976fc6f6-01d6-4101-880a-031e8301cbac:claude"}],"prompt_text":"Olen aloittamassa toiminimellä asiantuntijatyötä ja lähetän vain muutaman verkkolaskun kuukaudessa. Mikä ohjelmisto sopisi tähän tilanteeseen parhaiten?","prompt_type":"recommendation","share_of_voice":0,"companies_named":15,"visibility_rate":0,"consensus_answer":null,"consensus_claims":[],"completed_answers":6,"owned_citation_rate":0},{"id":"31b04bb3-99c4-43a1-b9f8-631326db080b","leader":{"is_self":false,"apex_domain":"procountor.fi","canonical_name":"Procountor"},"engines":["chatgpt","google_ai_overviews","google_ai_mode","gemini","perplexity","copilot","claude"],"outcomes":[{"rank":null,"engine":"chatgpt","status":"absent","evidence_ref":"31b04bb3-99c4-43a1-b9f8-631326db080b:chatgpt"},{"rank":null,"engine":"google_ai_overviews","status":"absent","evidence_ref":"31b04bb3-99c4-43a1-b9f8-631326db080b:google_ai_overviews"},{"rank":null,"engine":"google_ai_mode","status":"absent","evidence_ref":"31b04bb3-99c4-43a1-b9f8-631326db080b:google_ai_mode"},{"rank":null,"engine":"gemini","status":"absent","evidence_ref":"31b04bb3-99c4-43a1-b9f8-631326db080b:gemini"},{"rank":null,"engine":"perplexity","status":"failed","evidence_ref":null},{"rank":null,"engine":"copilot","status":"absent","evidence_ref":"31b04bb3-99c4-43a1-b9f8-631326db080b:copilot"},{"rank":null,"engine":"claude","status":"absent","evidence_ref":"31b04bb3-99c4-43a1-b9f8-631326db080b:claude"}],"prompt_text":"Kannattaako toiminimiyrittäjän ostaa sähköinen taloushallinto-ohjelma ja hoitaa laskutus itse, vai ulkoistaa koko taloushallinto suoraan tilitoimistolle?","prompt_type":"comparison","share_of_voice":0,"companies_named":11,"visibility_rate":0,"consensus_answer":"Toiminimiyrittäjälle suositellaan usein yhdistelmämallia, jossa laskutus hoidetaan itse sähköisellä ohjelmalla ja kirjanpito sekä veroasiat ulkoistetaan tilitoimistolle. Kaiken tekeminen itse pitää kulut pieninä, mutta vie aikaa ja jättää vastuut virheistä yrittäjälle. Täysi ulkoistus on kalleinta, mutta vapauttaa aikaa asiakastyöhön ja varmistaa asiantuntemuksen.","consensus_claims":[{"text":"Toiminimiyrittäjälle suositellaan usein yhdistelmämallia, jossa laskutus hoidetaan itse sähköisellä ohjelmalla ja kirjanpito sekä veroasiat ulkoistetaan tilitoimistolle.","sources":[{"engine":"chatgpt","evidence_ref":"31b04bb3-99c4-43a1-b9f8-631326db080b:chatgpt"},{"engine":"google_ai_overviews","evidence_ref":"31b04bb3-99c4-43a1-b9f8-631326db080b:google_ai_overviews"},{"engine":"google_ai_mode","evidence_ref":"31b04bb3-99c4-43a1-b9f8-631326db080b:google_ai_mode"},{"engine":"copilot","evidence_ref":"31b04bb3-99c4-43a1-b9f8-631326db080b:copilot"},{"engine":"claude","evidence_ref":"31b04bb3-99c4-43a1-b9f8-631326db080b:claude"}]},{"text":"Kaiken tekeminen itse pitää kulut pieninä, mutta vie aikaa ja jättää vastuut virheistä yrittäjälle.","sources":[{"engine":"chatgpt","evidence_ref":"31b04bb3-99c4-43a1-b9f8-631326db080b:chatgpt"},{"engine":"google_ai_mode","evidence_ref":"31b04bb3-99c4-43a1-b9f8-631326db080b:google_ai_mode"}]},{"text":"Täysi ulkoistus on kalleinta, mutta vapauttaa aikaa asiakastyöhön ja varmistaa asiantuntemuksen.","sources":[{"engine":"chatgpt","evidence_ref":"31b04bb3-99c4-43a1-b9f8-631326db080b:chatgpt"},{"engine":"google_ai_overviews","evidence_ref":"31b04bb3-99c4-43a1-b9f8-631326db080b:google_ai_overviews"},{"engine":"gemini","evidence_ref":"31b04bb3-99c4-43a1-b9f8-631326db080b:gemini"}]}],"completed_answers":6,"owned_citation_rate":0},{"id":"f0fe4f89-87df-490f-ab0b-2559782f2893","leader":{"is_self":false,"apex_domain":"procountor.fi","canonical_name":"Procountor"},"engines":["chatgpt","google_ai_overviews","google_ai_mode","gemini","perplexity","copilot","claude"],"outcomes":[{"rank":null,"engine":"chatgpt","status":"absent","evidence_ref":"f0fe4f89-87df-490f-ab0b-2559782f2893:chatgpt"},{"rank":null,"engine":"google_ai_overviews","status":"absent","evidence_ref":"f0fe4f89-87df-490f-ab0b-2559782f2893:google_ai_overviews"},{"rank":null,"engine":"google_ai_mode","status":"absent","evidence_ref":"f0fe4f89-87df-490f-ab0b-2559782f2893:google_ai_mode"},{"rank":null,"engine":"gemini","status":"absent","evidence_ref":"f0fe4f89-87df-490f-ab0b-2559782f2893:gemini"},{"rank":null,"engine":"perplexity","status":"failed","evidence_ref":null},{"rank":null,"engine":"copilot","status":"absent","evidence_ref":"f0fe4f89-87df-490f-ab0b-2559782f2893:copilot"},{"rank":null,"engine":"claude","status":"absent","evidence_ref":"f0fe4f89-87df-490f-ab0b-2559782f2893:claude"}],"prompt_text":"Käytän liikaa aikaa paperikuittien tallentamiseen ja laskujen tekemiseen Excelissä. Miten tämän rutiinin voisi automatisoida helpoiten pienyrityksessä?","prompt_type":"problem","share_of_voice":0,"companies_named":16,"visibility_rate":0,"consensus_answer":"Paperikuittien tallentamisen voi automatisoida kuvaamalla kuitit mobiilisovelluksella heti oston jälkeen, jolloin OCR-tekstintunnistus lukee summan, päivämäärän ja arvonlisäveron automaattisesti kirjanpitoon. Excel-laskutuksesta kannattaa siirtyä sähköiseen laskutusohjelmaan, joka hyödyntää asiakasrekistereitä, mahdollistaa verkkolaskutuksen sekä seuraa saapuvia maksuja pankkiyhteyden kautta.","consensus_claims":[{"text":"Paperikuittien tallentamisen voi automatisoida kuvaamalla kuitit mobiilisovelluksella heti oston jälkeen, jolloin OCR-tekstintunnistus lukee summan, päivämäärän ja arvonlisäveron automaattisesti kirjanpitoon.","sources":[{"engine":"chatgpt","evidence_ref":"f0fe4f89-87df-490f-ab0b-2559782f2893:chatgpt"},{"engine":"google_ai_overviews","evidence_ref":"f0fe4f89-87df-490f-ab0b-2559782f2893:google_ai_overviews"},{"engine":"copilot","evidence_ref":"f0fe4f89-87df-490f-ab0b-2559782f2893:copilot"}]},{"text":"Excel-laskutuksesta kannattaa siirtyä sähköiseen laskutusohjelmaan, joka hyödyntää asiakasrekistereitä, mahdollistaa verkkolaskutuksen sekä seuraa saapuvia maksuja pankkiyhteyden kautta.","sources":[{"engine":"google_ai_overviews","evidence_ref":"f0fe4f89-87df-490f-ab0b-2559782f2893:google_ai_overviews"},{"engine":"gemini","evidence_ref":"f0fe4f89-87df-490f-ab0b-2559782f2893:gemini"}]}],"completed_answers":6,"owned_citation_rate":0}],"attributes":{"role":"Founder and Sole Proprietor","needs":["Micro-business accounting software","Electronic invoicing and e-invoicing","Bank integration and transaction matching"],"industry":"Professional services","seniority":"Owner / C-Level","objections":["Monthly software subscription costs and transaction fees cutting into slim operational margins","Steep learning curve or excessive accounting jargon in software built primarily for certified accountants"],"pain_points":["Excessive billable hours lost to sorting paper receipts and entering invoice details manually","Anxiety over potential miscalculations or missed filing deadlines in official tax and VAT submissions"],"buying_roles":["decision_maker","end_user"],"company_size":"1–9 employees","current_tools":["Excel spreadsheets","Paper receipt archives","Standard online banking portals"],"buying_triggers":["Growing volume of customer receipts and vendor invoices making manual spreadsheet tracking unmanageable","Requirement to issue statutory Finnish e-invoices (Finvoice) and report VAT directly to OmaVero","Need to establish a streamlined, digital handover process with an external accounting agency (tilitoimisto)"],"generation_hint":"Base this persona on 'Micro-entrepreneur and Solo Trader'. Solo entrepreneur, freelancer, or small business founder seeking affordable, automated invoicing, receipt capture, and direct integration with Finnish banking and accounting. Typical roles: Founder, Sole Trader (Toiminimi), Managing Director. Buyer group: 'Small and micro enterprises (SMEs)' (B2B, 1–9 employees). They are looking for: Micro-business accounting software, Electronic invoicing and e-invoicing, Bank integration and transaction matching.","jobs_to_be_done":["Send professional electronic invoices compliant with Finnish standards to B2B clients","Capture and categorize business expense receipts digitally on the go","Reconcile customer payments automatically against bank account statements"],"desired_outcomes":["Minimal time spent on recurring administrative and bookkeeping tasks","Fewer errors and penalties in statutory VAT filings and tax reporting","Frictionless monthly financial data handoff to the external accountant"],"responsibilities":["Running core business operations and delivering customer projects","Managing business cash flow, client billing, and supplier payments","Organizing financial records for periodic accountant review and tax compliance"],"success_measures":["Hours saved each month on invoicing and receipt archiving","Zero late filing penalties or VAT reporting discrepancies with OmaVero","Speed of monthly bookkeeping closure by the external accountant"],"decision_criteria":["Direct compatibility with Finnish commercial banks for automated bank statement and payment feeds","Full support for domestic Finvoice e-invoicing and tax compliance standards","Straightforward interface designed for non-accountants with minimal training required","Transparent, predictable monthly subscription pricing with low per-transaction fees"],"organization_type":"private_company","alternatives_considered":["Manual bookkeeping using spreadsheets and paper receipt folders","Hiring an external bookkeeper to handle all invoicing and administrative data entry manually","Basic standalone invoicing tools without direct Finnish bank integration"]},"description":"Solo entrepreneur or micro-business founder operating in Finland seeking an intuitive, cost-effective digital accounting and invoicing solution. Responsible for all commercial operations and administrative tasks, this buyer needs to automate daily billing, expense capture, and bank reconciliation while ensuring smooth data sharing with their external accountant and compliance with Finnish tax authorities.","customer_type":"business","share_of_voice":0,"visibility_rate":0,"attribute_schema":"persona.business.v2","completed_answers":30,"owned_citation_rate":0},{"id":"cef03561-c7f6-413d-86d3-80ec981f8dd0","title":"Mid-market financial and operational leaders","market":"FI","prompts":[{"id":"2abd4047-ff2e-493d-95d3-21e445bd4b5a","leader":{"is_self":false,"apex_domain":"microsoft.com","canonical_name":"Microsoft"},"engines":["chatgpt","google_ai_overviews","google_ai_mode","gemini","perplexity","copilot","claude"],"outcomes":[{"rank":null,"engine":"chatgpt","status":"absent","evidence_ref":"2abd4047-ff2e-493d-95d3-21e445bd4b5a:chatgpt"},{"rank":null,"engine":"google_ai_overviews","status":"absent","evidence_ref":"2abd4047-ff2e-493d-95d3-21e445bd4b5a:google_ai_overviews"},{"rank":null,"engine":"google_ai_mode","status":"absent","evidence_ref":"2abd4047-ff2e-493d-95d3-21e445bd4b5a:google_ai_mode"},{"rank":null,"engine":"gemini","status":"absent","evidence_ref":"2abd4047-ff2e-493d-95d3-21e445bd4b5a:gemini"},{"rank":null,"engine":"perplexity","status":"failed","evidence_ref":null},{"rank":null,"engine":"copilot","status":"absent","evidence_ref":"2abd4047-ff2e-493d-95d3-21e445bd4b5a:copilot"},{"rank":null,"engine":"claude","status":"absent","evidence_ref":"2abd4047-ff2e-493d-95d3-21e445bd4b5a:claude"}],"prompt_text":"Pilvipohjainen ERP-järjestelmä valmistavalle pk-yritykselle Suomessa","prompt_type":"direct","share_of_voice":0,"companies_named":16,"visibility_rate":0,"consensus_answer":"Kotimainen Lemonsoft yhdistää tuotannonohjauksen, varaston ja taloushallinnon yhteen pilvipakettiin pk-yrityksille. Fikuro sopii nopeaa käyttöönottoa hakeville ja tarjoaa valmiit liitynnät Netvisoriin sekä Procountoriin. Monitor ERP keskittyy syvään tuotannonohjaukseen, kun taas Microsoft Dynamics 365 skaalautuu kansainvälisesti.","consensus_claims":[{"text":"Kotimainen Lemonsoft yhdistää tuotannonohjauksen, varaston ja taloushallinnon yhteen pilvipakettiin pk-yrityksille.","sources":[{"engine":"google_ai_overviews","evidence_ref":"2abd4047-ff2e-493d-95d3-21e445bd4b5a:google_ai_overviews"},{"engine":"google_ai_mode","evidence_ref":"2abd4047-ff2e-493d-95d3-21e445bd4b5a:google_ai_mode"},{"engine":"copilot","evidence_ref":"2abd4047-ff2e-493d-95d3-21e445bd4b5a:copilot"},{"engine":"claude","evidence_ref":"2abd4047-ff2e-493d-95d3-21e445bd4b5a:claude"}]},{"text":"Fikuro sopii nopeaa käyttöönottoa hakeville ja tarjoaa valmiit liitynnät Netvisoriin sekä Procountoriin.","sources":[{"engine":"chatgpt","evidence_ref":"2abd4047-ff2e-493d-95d3-21e445bd4b5a:chatgpt"},{"engine":"google_ai_overviews","evidence_ref":"2abd4047-ff2e-493d-95d3-21e445bd4b5a:google_ai_overviews"},{"engine":"claude","evidence_ref":"2abd4047-ff2e-493d-95d3-21e445bd4b5a:claude"}]},{"text":"Monitor ERP keskittyy syvään tuotannonohjaukseen, kun taas Microsoft Dynamics 365 skaalautuu kansainvälisesti.","sources":[{"engine":"chatgpt","evidence_ref":"2abd4047-ff2e-493d-95d3-21e445bd4b5a:chatgpt"},{"engine":"google_ai_mode","evidence_ref":"2abd4047-ff2e-493d-95d3-21e445bd4b5a:google_ai_mode"},{"engine":"gemini","evidence_ref":"2abd4047-ff2e-493d-95d3-21e445bd4b5a:gemini"},{"engine":"copilot","evidence_ref":"2abd4047-ff2e-493d-95d3-21e445bd4b5a:copilot"}]}],"completed_answers":6,"owned_citation_rate":0},{"id":"bf5e480b-02fb-4b6f-b698-7729f76c2a6c","leader":{"is_self":false,"apex_domain":"oscar.fi","canonical_name":"Oscar Software"},"engines":["chatgpt","google_ai_overviews","google_ai_mode","gemini","perplexity","copilot","claude"],"outcomes":[{"rank":null,"engine":"chatgpt","status":"absent","evidence_ref":"bf5e480b-02fb-4b6f-b698-7729f76c2a6c:chatgpt"},{"rank":null,"engine":"google_ai_overviews","status":"absent","evidence_ref":"bf5e480b-02fb-4b6f-b698-7729f76c2a6c:google_ai_overviews"},{"rank":null,"engine":"google_ai_mode","status":"failed","evidence_ref":null},{"rank":null,"engine":"gemini","status":"absent","evidence_ref":"bf5e480b-02fb-4b6f-b698-7729f76c2a6c:gemini"},{"rank":null,"engine":"perplexity","status":"failed","evidence_ref":null},{"rank":null,"engine":"copilot","status":"absent","evidence_ref":"bf5e480b-02fb-4b6f-b698-7729f76c2a6c:copilot"},{"rank":null,"engine":"claude","status":"absent","evidence_ref":"bf5e480b-02fb-4b6f-b698-7729f76c2a6c:claude"}],"prompt_text":"Mitä kotimaisia toiminnanohjaus- ja taloushallintojärjestelmiä on tarjolla teollisuuden ja tukkukaupan pk-yrityksille?","prompt_type":"discovery","share_of_voice":0,"companies_named":21,"visibility_rate":0,"consensus_answer":"Lemonsoft ja Oscar Software tarjoavat teollisuuden ja tukkukaupan pk-yrityksille laajat kotimaiset ERP-järjestelmät, jotka yhdistävät tuotannon, varaston ja taloushallinnon samaan kokonaisuuteen. Myös Visma Nova yhdistää taloushallinnon, tuotannon ja materiaalihallinnon teollisuudelle sekä tukkukaupalle.","consensus_claims":[{"text":"Lemonsoft ja Oscar Software tarjoavat teollisuuden ja tukkukaupan pk-yrityksille laajat kotimaiset ERP-järjestelmät, jotka yhdistävät tuotannon, varaston ja taloushallinnon samaan kokonaisuuteen.","sources":[{"engine":"chatgpt","evidence_ref":"bf5e480b-02fb-4b6f-b698-7729f76c2a6c:chatgpt"},{"engine":"google_ai_overviews","evidence_ref":"bf5e480b-02fb-4b6f-b698-7729f76c2a6c:google_ai_overviews"},{"engine":"gemini","evidence_ref":"bf5e480b-02fb-4b6f-b698-7729f76c2a6c:gemini"},{"engine":"copilot","evidence_ref":"bf5e480b-02fb-4b6f-b698-7729f76c2a6c:copilot"}]},{"text":"Myös Visma Nova yhdistää taloushallinnon, tuotannon ja materiaalihallinnon teollisuudelle sekä tukkukaupalle.","sources":[{"engine":"chatgpt","evidence_ref":"bf5e480b-02fb-4b6f-b698-7729f76c2a6c:chatgpt"},{"engine":"google_ai_overviews","evidence_ref":"bf5e480b-02fb-4b6f-b698-7729f76c2a6c:google_ai_overviews"},{"engine":"gemini","evidence_ref":"bf5e480b-02fb-4b6f-b698-7729f76c2a6c:gemini"},{"engine":"claude","evidence_ref":"bf5e480b-02fb-4b6f-b698-7729f76c2a6c:claude"}]}],"completed_answers":5,"owned_citation_rate":0},{"id":"bcf44be4-d9e6-4d43-b7bb-2bbd7fe357e9","leader":{"is_self":false,"apex_domain":"lemonsoft.fi","canonical_name":"Lemonsoft"},"engines":["chatgpt","google_ai_overviews","google_ai_mode","gemini","perplexity","copilot","claude"],"outcomes":[{"rank":null,"engine":"chatgpt","status":"absent","evidence_ref":"bcf44be4-d9e6-4d43-b7bb-2bbd7fe357e9:chatgpt"},{"rank":null,"engine":"google_ai_overviews","status":"absent","evidence_ref":"bcf44be4-d9e6-4d43-b7bb-2bbd7fe357e9:google_ai_overviews"},{"rank":null,"engine":"google_ai_mode","status":"absent","evidence_ref":"bcf44be4-d9e6-4d43-b7bb-2bbd7fe357e9:google_ai_mode"},{"rank":null,"engine":"gemini","status":"absent","evidence_ref":"bcf44be4-d9e6-4d43-b7bb-2bbd7fe357e9:gemini"},{"rank":null,"engine":"perplexity","status":"failed","evidence_ref":null},{"rank":null,"engine":"copilot","status":"absent","evidence_ref":"bcf44be4-d9e6-4d43-b7bb-2bbd7fe357e9:copilot"},{"rank":null,"engine":"claude","status":"absent","evidence_ref":"bcf44be4-d9e6-4d43-b7bb-2bbd7fe357e9:claude"}],"prompt_text":"Mikä ERP-järjestelmä sopii parhaiten noin 50 hengen suomalaiselle yritykselle, joka tarvitsee taloushallinnon, palkanlaskennan ja tuotannonohjauksen samaan pakettiin?","prompt_type":"recommendation","share_of_voice":0,"companies_named":12,"visibility_rate":0,"consensus_answer":"Lemonsoft tarjoaa suomalaiselle pk-teollisuudelle taloushallinnon, palkanlaskennan ja tuotannonohjauksen suoraan samassa järjestelmässä. Myös Visma Nova yhdistää kaikki kolme toimintoa saman katon alle ilman erillisiä ohjelmistoja. Oscar P1 kokoaa samoin talouden, palkat ja tuotannon kotimaiseen ERP-ratkaisuun.","consensus_claims":[{"text":"Lemonsoft tarjoaa suomalaiselle pk-teollisuudelle taloushallinnon, palkanlaskennan ja tuotannonohjauksen suoraan samassa järjestelmässä.","sources":[{"engine":"google_ai_overviews","evidence_ref":"bcf44be4-d9e6-4d43-b7bb-2bbd7fe357e9:google_ai_overviews"},{"engine":"gemini","evidence_ref":"bcf44be4-d9e6-4d43-b7bb-2bbd7fe357e9:gemini"},{"engine":"copilot","evidence_ref":"bcf44be4-d9e6-4d43-b7bb-2bbd7fe357e9:copilot"},{"engine":"claude","evidence_ref":"bcf44be4-d9e6-4d43-b7bb-2bbd7fe357e9:claude"}]},{"text":"Myös Visma Nova yhdistää kaikki kolme toimintoa saman katon alle ilman erillisiä ohjelmistoja.","sources":[{"engine":"chatgpt","evidence_ref":"bcf44be4-d9e6-4d43-b7bb-2bbd7fe357e9:chatgpt"},{"engine":"google_ai_overviews","evidence_ref":"bcf44be4-d9e6-4d43-b7bb-2bbd7fe357e9:google_ai_overviews"},{"engine":"claude","evidence_ref":"bcf44be4-d9e6-4d43-b7bb-2bbd7fe357e9:claude"}]},{"text":"Oscar P1 kokoaa samoin talouden, palkat ja tuotannon kotimaiseen ERP-ratkaisuun.","sources":[{"engine":"google_ai_overviews","evidence_ref":"bcf44be4-d9e6-4d43-b7bb-2bbd7fe357e9:google_ai_overviews"},{"engine":"google_ai_mode","evidence_ref":"bcf44be4-d9e6-4d43-b7bb-2bbd7fe357e9:google_ai_mode"}]}],"completed_answers":6,"owned_citation_rate":0},{"id":"9665e4ac-de3e-42a6-95c4-e893cd990966","leader":{"is_self":false,"apex_domain":"netvisor.fi","canonical_name":"Netvisor"},"engines":["chatgpt","google_ai_overviews","google_ai_mode","gemini","perplexity","copilot","claude"],"outcomes":[{"rank":null,"engine":"chatgpt","status":"absent","evidence_ref":"9665e4ac-de3e-42a6-95c4-e893cd990966:chatgpt"},{"rank":null,"engine":"google_ai_overviews","status":"absent","evidence_ref":"9665e4ac-de3e-42a6-95c4-e893cd990966:google_ai_overviews"},{"rank":null,"engine":"google_ai_mode","status":"absent","evidence_ref":"9665e4ac-de3e-42a6-95c4-e893cd990966:google_ai_mode"},{"rank":null,"engine":"gemini","status":"absent","evidence_ref":"9665e4ac-de3e-42a6-95c4-e893cd990966:gemini"},{"rank":null,"engine":"perplexity","status":"failed","evidence_ref":null},{"rank":null,"engine":"copilot","status":"absent","evidence_ref":"9665e4ac-de3e-42a6-95c4-e893cd990966:copilot"},{"rank":null,"engine":"claude","status":"absent","evidence_ref":"9665e4ac-de3e-42a6-95c4-e893cd990966:claude"}],"prompt_text":"Kannattaako keskisuuren yrityksen hankkia yhtenäinen ERP-järjestelmä vai erilliset ohjelmistot taloushallintoon ja varastonhallintaan?","prompt_type":"comparison","share_of_voice":0,"companies_named":2,"visibility_rate":0,"consensus_answer":"Keskisuurelle yritykselle yhtenäinen ERP-järjestelmä on usein kannattavampi valinta kuin erilliset ohjelmistot. Se tarjoaa reaaliaikaisen tiedonkulun ja vähentää manuaalista työtä yhdistämällä talous- ja varastotiedot samaan kantaan. Erilliset ohjelmistot puolestaan mahdollistavat kuhunkin tarpeeseen parhaat täsmätyökalut, mutta vaativat integraatioita.","consensus_claims":[{"text":"Keskisuurelle yritykselle yhtenäinen ERP-järjestelmä on usein kannattavampi valinta kuin erilliset ohjelmistot.","sources":[{"engine":"chatgpt","evidence_ref":"9665e4ac-de3e-42a6-95c4-e893cd990966:chatgpt"},{"engine":"google_ai_overviews","evidence_ref":"9665e4ac-de3e-42a6-95c4-e893cd990966:google_ai_overviews"},{"engine":"google_ai_mode","evidence_ref":"9665e4ac-de3e-42a6-95c4-e893cd990966:google_ai_mode"},{"engine":"copilot","evidence_ref":"9665e4ac-de3e-42a6-95c4-e893cd990966:copilot"}]},{"text":"Se tarjoaa reaaliaikaisen tiedonkulun ja vähentää manuaalista työtä yhdistämällä talous- ja varastotiedot samaan kantaan.","sources":[{"engine":"chatgpt","evidence_ref":"9665e4ac-de3e-42a6-95c4-e893cd990966:chatgpt"},{"engine":"google_ai_mode","evidence_ref":"9665e4ac-de3e-42a6-95c4-e893cd990966:google_ai_mode"},{"engine":"gemini","evidence_ref":"9665e4ac-de3e-42a6-95c4-e893cd990966:gemini"},{"engine":"claude","evidence_ref":"9665e4ac-de3e-42a6-95c4-e893cd990966:claude"}]},{"text":"Erilliset ohjelmistot puolestaan mahdollistavat kuhunkin tarpeeseen parhaat täsmätyökalut, mutta vaativat integraatioita.","sources":[{"engine":"google_ai_overviews","evidence_ref":"9665e4ac-de3e-42a6-95c4-e893cd990966:google_ai_overviews"},{"engine":"gemini","evidence_ref":"9665e4ac-de3e-42a6-95c4-e893cd990966:gemini"},{"engine":"copilot","evidence_ref":"9665e4ac-de3e-42a6-95c4-e893cd990966:copilot"}]}],"completed_answers":6,"owned_citation_rate":0},{"id":"e765d362-7a2c-42a5-962c-27df22757d8f","leader":{"is_self":false,"apex_domain":"lemonsoft.fi","canonical_name":"Lemonsoft"},"engines":["chatgpt","google_ai_overviews","google_ai_mode","gemini","perplexity","copilot","claude"],"outcomes":[{"rank":null,"engine":"chatgpt","status":"absent","evidence_ref":"e765d362-7a2c-42a5-962c-27df22757d8f:chatgpt"},{"rank":null,"engine":"google_ai_overviews","status":"absent","evidence_ref":"e765d362-7a2c-42a5-962c-27df22757d8f:google_ai_overviews"},{"rank":null,"engine":"google_ai_mode","status":"absent","evidence_ref":"e765d362-7a2c-42a5-962c-27df22757d8f:google_ai_mode"},{"rank":null,"engine":"gemini","status":"absent","evidence_ref":"e765d362-7a2c-42a5-962c-27df22757d8f:gemini"},{"rank":null,"engine":"perplexity","status":"failed","evidence_ref":null},{"rank":null,"engine":"copilot","status":"absent","evidence_ref":"e765d362-7a2c-42a5-962c-27df22757d8f:copilot"},{"rank":null,"engine":"claude","status":"absent","evidence_ref":"e765d362-7a2c-42a5-962c-27df22757d8f:claude"}],"prompt_text":"Miten yhdistää tuotannonohjaus, varastosaldojen seuranta ja kirjanpito, kun Excel-taulukot eivät enää riitä?","prompt_type":"problem","share_of_voice":0,"companies_named":12,"visibility_rate":0,"consensus_answer":null,"consensus_claims":[],"completed_answers":6,"owned_citation_rate":0}],"attributes":{"role":"Chief Financial Officer or Operations Director","needs":["Comprehensive cloud ERP platform covering supply chain, manufacturing, and financials","Automated financial management with direct bank connectivity for statement reconciliation and outgoing payments","Integrated Finnish payroll and human resources administration modules"],"industry":"Industrial manufacturing and wholesale trade","seniority":"Executive Director","objections":["High upfront switching and deployment costs relative to budgeted capital expenditures","Risk of operational downtime during business-critical data migration from legacy databases","Internal resistance from staff accustomed to long-standing manual processes and legacy interfaces"],"pain_points":["Siloed information between sales, inventory, shop-floor operations, and the financial ledger","Heavy reliance on manual spreadsheet consolidations that introduce reporting discrepancies","Slow and fragmented financial closing cycles caused by delayed paperwork from operational teams"],"buying_roles":["decision_maker","executive_sponsor"],"company_size":"10–500 employees","current_tools":["Legacy on-premise ERP system","Basic standalone bookkeeping software","Spreadsheets for inventory and production tracking"],"buying_triggers":["Outgrowing basic standalone accounting tools as operational and supply chain complexities expand","Board mandate to transition from legacy on-premise infrastructure to a unified cloud platform","Persistent lack of real-time visibility into inventory levels, job costing, and overall operational margins"],"generation_hint":"Base this persona on 'SME Financial Director / Operations Manager'. Financial or operational executive at an established Finnish mid-market enterprise looking for an integrated ERP covering financials, supply chain, production, and payroll. Typical roles: Chief Financial Officer (CFO), Financial Director, Chief Operating Officer (COO), Managing Director. Buyer group: 'Mid-sized industrial and commercial enterprises' (B2B, 10–500+ employees). They are looking for: Comprehensive cloud ERP platform, Automated financial management and reporting, Payroll and HR administration.","jobs_to_be_done":["Unify fragmented departmental data into a single source of operational truth","Automate month-end financial closing, VAT reporting via OmaVero, and payroll calculations","Track production schedules, inventory turnover, and job profitability in real time"],"desired_outcomes":["Consolidated real-time reporting across corporate finances, inventory, and production units","Automated statutory tax filings and e-invoicing compliant with Finnish regulatory authorities","Reduced administrative overhead and eliminated duplicate data entry across departments","Predictable software operating expenditures through a scalable cloud model"],"responsibilities":["Overseeing organizational financial planning, cash flow, and statutory compliance","Ensuring smooth cross-departmental operations and production scheduling","Evaluating and approving enterprise software investments and digital modernization initiatives"],"success_measures":["Time saved per month during financial closing and statutory reporting","Improvement in inventory forecasting accuracy and order fulfillment velocity","Lower total cost of system maintenance compared to legacy on-premise infrastructure"],"decision_criteria":["Native compliance with Finnish statutory standards such as OmaVero VAT reporting, Finvoice, and local payroll regulations","Depth of integrated modules spanning inventory control, production management, and financial ledgers","Direct integration with Finnish commercial banking networks for automated payment runs and reconciliation","Total cost of ownership across monthly subscription tiers, user licensing, and ongoing maintenance","Reliability of data migration paths and implementation support services"],"organization_type":"private_company","alternatives_considered":["Upgrading existing legacy on-premise ERP modules","Maintaining standalone basic accounting software combined with external spreadsheets","Hiring an external consulting firm to build custom point-to-point integrations","Outsourcing all payroll and specialized reporting to an external agency"]},"description":"Financial and operational executives at established mid-sized Finnish enterprises facing operational bottlenecks caused by disconnected software systems. They are seeking a unified cloud ERP platform that seamlessly connects core accounting, statutory tax reporting, inventory, manufacturing, and payroll into a single operational view.","customer_type":"business","share_of_voice":0,"visibility_rate":0,"attribute_schema":"persona.business.v2","completed_answers":29,"owned_citation_rate":0},{"id":"854f4c50-d340-44bf-87d8-aed893bd5bd3","title":"Accounting agency managing directors","market":"FI","prompts":[{"id":"69f4eff6-dd7f-4a0d-b78e-aab3e1f3c1cd","leader":{"is_self":false,"apex_domain":"fennoa.fi","canonical_name":"Fennoa"},"engines":["chatgpt","google_ai_overviews","google_ai_mode","gemini","perplexity","copilot","claude"],"outcomes":[{"rank":null,"engine":"chatgpt","status":"absent","evidence_ref":"69f4eff6-dd7f-4a0d-b78e-aab3e1f3c1cd:chatgpt"},{"rank":null,"engine":"google_ai_overviews","status":"absent","evidence_ref":"69f4eff6-dd7f-4a0d-b78e-aab3e1f3c1cd:google_ai_overviews"},{"rank":null,"engine":"google_ai_mode","status":"absent","evidence_ref":"69f4eff6-dd7f-4a0d-b78e-aab3e1f3c1cd:google_ai_mode"},{"rank":null,"engine":"gemini","status":"absent","evidence_ref":"69f4eff6-dd7f-4a0d-b78e-aab3e1f3c1cd:gemini"},{"rank":null,"engine":"perplexity","status":"failed","evidence_ref":null},{"rank":null,"engine":"copilot","status":"absent","evidence_ref":"69f4eff6-dd7f-4a0d-b78e-aab3e1f3c1cd:copilot"},{"rank":null,"engine":"claude","status":"absent","evidence_ref":"69f4eff6-dd7f-4a0d-b78e-aab3e1f3c1cd:claude"}],"prompt_text":"Mikä on paras sähköisen taloushallinnon ohjelmisto tilitoimistolle moniasiakashallintaan?","prompt_type":"direct","share_of_voice":0,"companies_named":7,"visibility_rate":0,"consensus_answer":"Tilitoimiston moniasiakashallintaan ei ole yhtä ainoaa parasta ratkaisua, mutta yleisimmiksi kärkivaihtoehdoiksi nostetaan Fennoa, Netvisor ja Procountor. Netvisor erottuu vahvoilla rajapinnoilla ja integraatioilla, kun taas Fennoa on suunniteltu suoraan tilitoimistojen tarpeisiin ja helppokäyttöisyyteen.","consensus_claims":[{"text":"Tilitoimiston moniasiakashallintaan ei ole yhtä ainoaa parasta ratkaisua, mutta yleisimmiksi kärkivaihtoehdoiksi nostetaan Fennoa, Netvisor ja Procountor.","sources":[{"engine":"chatgpt","evidence_ref":"69f4eff6-dd7f-4a0d-b78e-aab3e1f3c1cd:chatgpt"},{"engine":"google_ai_overviews","evidence_ref":"69f4eff6-dd7f-4a0d-b78e-aab3e1f3c1cd:google_ai_overviews"},{"engine":"google_ai_mode","evidence_ref":"69f4eff6-dd7f-4a0d-b78e-aab3e1f3c1cd:google_ai_mode"},{"engine":"claude","evidence_ref":"69f4eff6-dd7f-4a0d-b78e-aab3e1f3c1cd:claude"}]},{"text":"Netvisor erottuu vahvoilla rajapinnoilla ja integraatioilla, kun taas Fennoa on suunniteltu suoraan tilitoimistojen tarpeisiin ja helppokäyttöisyyteen.","sources":[{"engine":"google_ai_overviews","evidence_ref":"69f4eff6-dd7f-4a0d-b78e-aab3e1f3c1cd:google_ai_overviews"},{"engine":"copilot","evidence_ref":"69f4eff6-dd7f-4a0d-b78e-aab3e1f3c1cd:copilot"}]}],"completed_answers":6,"owned_citation_rate":0},{"id":"05c4bb05-3001-4fd6-af11-722e44deca2f","leader":{"is_self":false,"apex_domain":"fennoa.fi","canonical_name":"Fennoa"},"engines":["chatgpt","google_ai_overviews","google_ai_mode","gemini","perplexity","copilot","claude"],"outcomes":[{"rank":null,"engine":"chatgpt","status":"absent","evidence_ref":"05c4bb05-3001-4fd6-af11-722e44deca2f:chatgpt"},{"rank":null,"engine":"google_ai_overviews","status":"absent","evidence_ref":"05c4bb05-3001-4fd6-af11-722e44deca2f:google_ai_overviews"},{"rank":null,"engine":"google_ai_mode","status":"absent","evidence_ref":"05c4bb05-3001-4fd6-af11-722e44deca2f:google_ai_mode"},{"rank":null,"engine":"gemini","status":"absent","evidence_ref":"05c4bb05-3001-4fd6-af11-722e44deca2f:gemini"},{"rank":null,"engine":"perplexity","status":"failed","evidence_ref":null},{"rank":null,"engine":"copilot","status":"absent","evidence_ref":"05c4bb05-3001-4fd6-af11-722e44deca2f:copilot"},{"rank":null,"engine":"claude","status":"absent","evidence_ref":"05c4bb05-3001-4fd6-af11-722e44deca2f:claude"}],"prompt_text":"Mitä pilvipohjaisia kirjanpito- ja palkanlaskentaohjelmistoja on saatavilla tilitoimistoille Suomessa?","prompt_type":"discovery","share_of_voice":0,"companies_named":24,"visibility_rate":0,"consensus_answer":null,"consensus_claims":[],"completed_answers":6,"owned_citation_rate":0},{"id":"83c8e769-9877-468e-9906-5ddd057e021a","leader":{"is_self":false,"apex_domain":"fennoa.fi","canonical_name":"Fennoa"},"engines":["chatgpt","google_ai_overviews","google_ai_mode","gemini","perplexity","copilot","claude"],"outcomes":[{"rank":null,"engine":"chatgpt","status":"absent","evidence_ref":"83c8e769-9877-468e-9906-5ddd057e021a:chatgpt"},{"rank":null,"engine":"google_ai_overviews","status":"absent","evidence_ref":"83c8e769-9877-468e-9906-5ddd057e021a:google_ai_overviews"},{"rank":null,"engine":"google_ai_mode","status":"absent","evidence_ref":"83c8e769-9877-468e-9906-5ddd057e021a:google_ai_mode"},{"rank":null,"engine":"gemini","status":"failed","evidence_ref":null},{"rank":null,"engine":"perplexity","status":"failed","evidence_ref":null},{"rank":null,"engine":"copilot","status":"absent","evidence_ref":"83c8e769-9877-468e-9906-5ddd057e021a:copilot"},{"rank":null,"engine":"claude","status":"absent","evidence_ref":"83c8e769-9877-468e-9906-5ddd057e021a:claude"}],"prompt_text":"Mikä taloushallinto-ohjelmisto sopii parhaiten kasvavalle tilitoimistolle, joka haluaa automatisoida lakisääteiset viranomaisilmoitukset ja pankkiyhteydet?","prompt_type":"recommendation","share_of_voice":0,"companies_named":7,"visibility_rate":0,"consensus_answer":null,"consensus_claims":[],"completed_answers":5,"owned_citation_rate":0},{"id":"f26d58b5-8eb4-42a2-8853-48dc2cff93bf","leader":{"is_self":false,"apex_domain":"procountor.fi","canonical_name":"Procountor"},"engines":["chatgpt","google_ai_overviews","google_ai_mode","gemini","perplexity","copilot","claude"],"outcomes":[{"rank":null,"engine":"chatgpt","status":"absent","evidence_ref":"f26d58b5-8eb4-42a2-8853-48dc2cff93bf:chatgpt"},{"rank":null,"engine":"google_ai_overviews","status":"absent","evidence_ref":"f26d58b5-8eb4-42a2-8853-48dc2cff93bf:google_ai_overviews"},{"rank":null,"engine":"google_ai_mode","status":"absent","evidence_ref":"f26d58b5-8eb4-42a2-8853-48dc2cff93bf:google_ai_mode"},{"rank":null,"engine":"gemini","status":"absent","evidence_ref":"f26d58b5-8eb4-42a2-8853-48dc2cff93bf:gemini"},{"rank":null,"engine":"perplexity","status":"failed","evidence_ref":null},{"rank":null,"engine":"copilot","status":"absent","evidence_ref":"f26d58b5-8eb4-42a2-8853-48dc2cff93bf:copilot"},{"rank":null,"engine":"claude","status":"absent","evidence_ref":"f26d58b5-8eb4-42a2-8853-48dc2cff93bf:claude"}],"prompt_text":"Kannattaako tilitoimiston käyttää yhtä integroitua taloushallintojärjestelmää vai erillisiä ohjelmistoja kirjanpitoon ja palkanlaskentaan?","prompt_type":"comparison","share_of_voice":0,"companies_named":8,"visibility_rate":0,"consensus_answer":"Tilitoimiston kannattaa yleensä suosia yhtä integroitua järjestelmää, koska se tehostaa työtä, vähentää virheitä ja siirtää palkkatiedot automaattisesti kirjanpitoon. Erilliset ohjelmistot ovat kuitenkin perusteltuja, jos palkanlaskenta on poikkeuksellisen monimutkaista tai asiakkailla sovelletaan vaativia työehtosopimuksia.","consensus_claims":[{"text":"Tilitoimiston kannattaa yleensä suosia yhtä integroitua järjestelmää, koska se tehostaa työtä, vähentää virheitä ja siirtää palkkatiedot automaattisesti kirjanpitoon.","sources":[{"engine":"chatgpt","evidence_ref":"f26d58b5-8eb4-42a2-8853-48dc2cff93bf:chatgpt"},{"engine":"google_ai_overviews","evidence_ref":"f26d58b5-8eb4-42a2-8853-48dc2cff93bf:google_ai_overviews"},{"engine":"google_ai_mode","evidence_ref":"f26d58b5-8eb4-42a2-8853-48dc2cff93bf:google_ai_mode"},{"engine":"copilot","evidence_ref":"f26d58b5-8eb4-42a2-8853-48dc2cff93bf:copilot"},{"engine":"claude","evidence_ref":"f26d58b5-8eb4-42a2-8853-48dc2cff93bf:claude"}]},{"text":"Erilliset ohjelmistot ovat kuitenkin perusteltuja, jos palkanlaskenta on poikkeuksellisen monimutkaista tai asiakkailla sovelletaan vaativia työehtosopimuksia.","sources":[{"engine":"google_ai_overviews","evidence_ref":"f26d58b5-8eb4-42a2-8853-48dc2cff93bf:google_ai_overviews"},{"engine":"google_ai_mode","evidence_ref":"f26d58b5-8eb4-42a2-8853-48dc2cff93bf:google_ai_mode"},{"engine":"copilot","evidence_ref":"f26d58b5-8eb4-42a2-8853-48dc2cff93bf:copilot"}]}],"completed_answers":6,"owned_citation_rate":0},{"id":"6b7f1e6d-a7be-4407-afd1-b79dc7a0283e","leader":{"is_self":false,"apex_domain":"procountor.fi","canonical_name":"Procountor"},"engines":["chatgpt","google_ai_overviews","google_ai_mode","gemini","perplexity","copilot","claude"],"outcomes":[{"rank":null,"engine":"chatgpt","status":"absent","evidence_ref":"6b7f1e6d-a7be-4407-afd1-b79dc7a0283e:chatgpt"},{"rank":null,"engine":"google_ai_overviews","status":"absent","evidence_ref":"6b7f1e6d-a7be-4407-afd1-b79dc7a0283e:google_ai_overviews"},{"rank":null,"engine":"google_ai_mode","status":"absent","evidence_ref":"6b7f1e6d-a7be-4407-afd1-b79dc7a0283e:google_ai_mode"},{"rank":null,"engine":"gemini","status":"failed","evidence_ref":null},{"rank":null,"engine":"perplexity","status":"failed","evidence_ref":null},{"rank":null,"engine":"copilot","status":"absent","evidence_ref":"6b7f1e6d-a7be-4407-afd1-b79dc7a0283e:copilot"},{"rank":null,"engine":"claude","status":"absent","evidence_ref":"6b7f1e6d-a7be-4407-afd1-b79dc7a0283e:claude"}],"prompt_text":"Miten automatisoida tilitoimiston kuukaudenvaihteen raportointi ja palkkojen ilmoittaminen tulorekisteriin?","prompt_type":"problem","share_of_voice":0,"companies_named":6,"visibility_rate":0,"consensus_answer":null,"consensus_claims":[],"completed_answers":5,"owned_citation_rate":0}],"attributes":{"role":"Managing Partner","needs":["Automated financial management and reporting","Payroll and HR administration","Direct integration with Finnish tax and pension reporting channels","Automated bank reconciliation and electronic invoice processing for multiple client entities"],"industry":"Accounting and financial services","seniority":"Executive","objections":["High switching costs and time required to migrate existing client histories from incumbent software","Risk of workflow disruption during peak financial year-end or tax reporting cycles","Unfavorable pricing tiers that penalize high client or transaction volumes"],"pain_points":["Excessive time spent cross-checking manual payroll entries and reconciling client accounts across disconnected systems","Bottlenecks during month-end reporting periods due to lack of automated reporting tools","Human error risks in statutory tax and wage submissions leading to administrative penalties"],"buying_roles":["decision_maker","executive_sponsor"],"company_size":"1–100+ employees","current_tools":["Disparate legacy client accounting software","Spreadsheets for time-tracking and payroll runs","Manual portal submissions for tax and statutory reporting"],"buying_triggers":["Client roster growth making manual payroll calculations and bespoke monthly reporting unsustainable","Regulatory updates and direct reporting requirements to Finnish tax and pension authorities straining current workflow efficiency","Clients demanding real-time digital access to automated financial management reports and payroll data"],"generation_hint":"Base this persona on a buyer from 'Accounting and financial service agencies' (B2B, 1–100+ employees). They are looking for: Automated financial management and reporting, Payroll and HR administration.","jobs_to_be_done":["Manage multi-client bookkeeping, ledger accounts, and VAT reconciliation accurately","Run monthly and bi-weekly client payroll including pension, tax withholding, and benefit calculations","Generate consolidated and client-specific financial statements and operational reports","Submit statutory filings directly to relevant Finnish government registries"],"desired_outcomes":["Faster monthly close and reporting cycles across all client accounts","Zero-error payroll runs with automated submission of earnings data to national registries","Increased capacity for client advisory services without increasing administrative headcount","Unified client portfolio oversight in a single cloud interface"],"responsibilities":["Overseeing agency operational efficiency and service quality for client bookkeeping and payroll","Evaluating and adopting software infrastructure used by agency staff and shared with clients","Ensuring practice-wide compliance with Finnish financial regulations and filing deadlines"],"success_measures":["Reduction in billable hours spent on routine payroll calculation and statutory filings","Number of active client portfolios managed per accountant","Client satisfaction and retention rates tied to reporting turnaround time"],"decision_criteria":["Full compliance with Finnish accounting standards, VAT reporting via OmaVero, and national payroll reporting systems","Multi-client management capabilities with role-based client collaboration portals","Reliability and accuracy of automated financial reporting and recurring payroll calculations","Scalability of SaaS subscription and per-client licensing fees"],"organization_type":"private_company","alternatives_considered":["Legacy desktop accounting and payroll software","Manual spreadsheet-based calculations for client payroll and reporting","Separate standalone payroll and bookkeeping tools stitched together via manual exports","Hiring additional accounting staff instead of adopting automated software"]},"description":"Senior partner or managing director at an independent Finnish accounting agency (tilitoimisto) modernizing client service delivery. They oversee bookkeeping, financial reporting, and payroll for a diverse portfolio of business clients, seeking unified cloud software that automates core accounting workflows, reduces administrative overhead, and ensures strict compliance with Finnish statutory authorities.","customer_type":"business","share_of_voice":0,"visibility_rate":0,"attribute_schema":"persona.business.v2","completed_answers":28,"owned_citation_rate":0},{"id":"a98ff54d-c194-4f84-b493-b6b8f2b855ba","title":"Multi-entity corporate IT directors","market":"FI","prompts":[{"id":"d63a2e74-5633-46d2-b1b5-2af1202a003f","leader":{"is_self":false,"apex_domain":"microsoft.com","canonical_name":"Microsoft"},"engines":["chatgpt","google_ai_overviews","google_ai_mode","gemini","perplexity","copilot","claude"],"outcomes":[{"rank":null,"engine":"chatgpt","status":"absent","evidence_ref":"d63a2e74-5633-46d2-b1b5-2af1202a003f:chatgpt"},{"rank":null,"engine":"google_ai_overviews","status":"failed","evidence_ref":null},{"rank":null,"engine":"google_ai_mode","status":"absent","evidence_ref":"d63a2e74-5633-46d2-b1b5-2af1202a003f:google_ai_mode"},{"rank":null,"engine":"gemini","status":"absent","evidence_ref":"d63a2e74-5633-46d2-b1b5-2af1202a003f:gemini"},{"rank":null,"engine":"perplexity","status":"failed","evidence_ref":null},{"rank":null,"engine":"copilot","status":"absent","evidence_ref":"d63a2e74-5633-46d2-b1b5-2af1202a003f:copilot"},{"rank":null,"engine":"claude","status":"absent","evidence_ref":"d63a2e74-5633-46d2-b1b5-2af1202a003f:claude"}],"prompt_text":"Pilvipohjainen ERP-järjestelmä moniyrityskonsernille Suomessa","prompt_type":"direct","share_of_voice":0,"companies_named":13,"visibility_rate":0,"consensus_answer":null,"consensus_claims":[],"completed_answers":5,"owned_citation_rate":0},{"id":"85a529b3-78c6-45d9-be51-12ec4b5dbd97","leader":{"is_self":false,"apex_domain":"microsoft.com","canonical_name":"Microsoft"},"engines":["chatgpt","google_ai_overviews","google_ai_mode","gemini","perplexity","copilot","claude"],"outcomes":[{"rank":null,"engine":"chatgpt","status":"absent","evidence_ref":"85a529b3-78c6-45d9-be51-12ec4b5dbd97:chatgpt"},{"rank":null,"engine":"google_ai_overviews","status":"absent","evidence_ref":"85a529b3-78c6-45d9-be51-12ec4b5dbd97:google_ai_overviews"},{"rank":null,"engine":"google_ai_mode","status":"absent","evidence_ref":"85a529b3-78c6-45d9-be51-12ec4b5dbd97:google_ai_mode"},{"rank":null,"engine":"gemini","status":"absent","evidence_ref":"85a529b3-78c6-45d9-be51-12ec4b5dbd97:gemini"},{"rank":null,"engine":"perplexity","status":"failed","evidence_ref":null},{"rank":null,"engine":"copilot","status":"absent","evidence_ref":"85a529b3-78c6-45d9-be51-12ec4b5dbd97:copilot"},{"rank":null,"engine":"claude","status":"absent","evidence_ref":"85a529b3-78c6-45d9-be51-12ec4b5dbd97:claude"}],"prompt_text":"Mitä pilvi-ERP-ratkaisuja on tarjolla suomalaisille konserneille, joilla on useita itsenäisiä tytäryhtiöitä?","prompt_type":"discovery","share_of_voice":0,"companies_named":20,"visibility_rate":0,"consensus_answer":"Keskisuurille konserneille suositellaan järjestelmää Microsoft Dynamics 365 Business Central, joka mahdollistaa useiden yhtiöiden hallinnan ja integroituu laajasti Microsoft-ekosysteemiin. Kansainvälisille moniyhtiörakenteille tarjotaan ratkaisua Oracle NetSuite, joka tukee tytäryhtiökohtaista kirjanpitoa, useita valuuttoja sekä reaaliaikaista konserniraportointia.","consensus_claims":[{"text":"Keskisuurille konserneille suositellaan järjestelmää Microsoft Dynamics 365 Business Central, joka mahdollistaa useiden yhtiöiden hallinnan ja integroituu laajasti Microsoft-ekosysteemiin.","sources":[{"engine":"chatgpt","evidence_ref":"85a529b3-78c6-45d9-be51-12ec4b5dbd97:chatgpt"},{"engine":"google_ai_overviews","evidence_ref":"85a529b3-78c6-45d9-be51-12ec4b5dbd97:google_ai_overviews"},{"engine":"google_ai_mode","evidence_ref":"85a529b3-78c6-45d9-be51-12ec4b5dbd97:google_ai_mode"},{"engine":"gemini","evidence_ref":"85a529b3-78c6-45d9-be51-12ec4b5dbd97:gemini"},{"engine":"copilot","evidence_ref":"85a529b3-78c6-45d9-be51-12ec4b5dbd97:copilot"}]},{"text":"Kansainvälisille moniyhtiörakenteille tarjotaan ratkaisua Oracle NetSuite, joka tukee tytäryhtiökohtaista kirjanpitoa, useita valuuttoja sekä reaaliaikaista konserniraportointia.","sources":[{"engine":"chatgpt","evidence_ref":"85a529b3-78c6-45d9-be51-12ec4b5dbd97:chatgpt"},{"engine":"google_ai_overviews","evidence_ref":"85a529b3-78c6-45d9-be51-12ec4b5dbd97:google_ai_overviews"},{"engine":"google_ai_mode","evidence_ref":"85a529b3-78c6-45d9-be51-12ec4b5dbd97:google_ai_mode"},{"engine":"gemini","evidence_ref":"85a529b3-78c6-45d9-be51-12ec4b5dbd97:gemini"},{"engine":"copilot","evidence_ref":"85a529b3-78c6-45d9-be51-12ec4b5dbd97:copilot"}]}],"completed_answers":6,"owned_citation_rate":0},{"id":"efc6830e-7e8e-433d-ac7d-27ad56ed31a8","leader":{"is_self":false,"apex_domain":"microsoft.com","canonical_name":"Microsoft"},"engines":["chatgpt","google_ai_overviews","google_ai_mode","gemini","perplexity","copilot","claude"],"outcomes":[{"rank":null,"engine":"chatgpt","status":"absent","evidence_ref":"efc6830e-7e8e-433d-ac7d-27ad56ed31a8:chatgpt"},{"rank":null,"engine":"google_ai_overviews","status":"absent","evidence_ref":"efc6830e-7e8e-433d-ac7d-27ad56ed31a8:google_ai_overviews"},{"rank":null,"engine":"google_ai_mode","status":"absent","evidence_ref":"efc6830e-7e8e-433d-ac7d-27ad56ed31a8:google_ai_mode"},{"rank":null,"engine":"gemini","status":"absent","evidence_ref":"efc6830e-7e8e-433d-ac7d-27ad56ed31a8:gemini"},{"rank":null,"engine":"perplexity","status":"failed","evidence_ref":null},{"rank":null,"engine":"copilot","status":"absent","evidence_ref":"efc6830e-7e8e-433d-ac7d-27ad56ed31a8:copilot"},{"rank":null,"engine":"claude","status":"absent","evidence_ref":"efc6830e-7e8e-433d-ac7d-27ad56ed31a8:claude"}],"prompt_text":"Mikä ERP-järjestelmä sopii parhaiten konsernille, jossa tarvitaan automatisoitua konsernilaskentaa, avoimia rajapintoja sekä suorat suomalaiset pankki- ja OmaVero-yhteydet?","prompt_type":"recommendation","share_of_voice":0,"companies_named":12,"visibility_rate":0,"consensus_answer":"Microsoft Dynamics 365 Business Central tarjoaa vahvan moniyhtiötuen ja avoimet rajapinnat, mutta suorat suomalaiset pankki- ja OmaVero-yhteydet vaativat usein kumppanin lokalisointiratkaisuja tai lisäosia. Kotimainen Netvisor sisältää valmiit suorat yhteydet Suomen pankkeihin ja verottajan palveluihin sekä automaattisen sisäisten erien eliminoinnin talouspainotteisille konserneille.","consensus_claims":[{"text":"Microsoft Dynamics 365 Business Central tarjoaa vahvan moniyhtiötuen ja avoimet rajapinnat, mutta suorat suomalaiset pankki- ja OmaVero-yhteydet vaativat usein kumppanin lokalisointiratkaisuja tai lisäosia.","sources":[{"engine":"google_ai_overviews","evidence_ref":"efc6830e-7e8e-433d-ac7d-27ad56ed31a8:google_ai_overviews"},{"engine":"copilot","evidence_ref":"efc6830e-7e8e-433d-ac7d-27ad56ed31a8:copilot"},{"engine":"claude","evidence_ref":"efc6830e-7e8e-433d-ac7d-27ad56ed31a8:claude"}]},{"text":"Kotimainen Netvisor sisältää valmiit suorat yhteydet Suomen pankkeihin ja verottajan palveluihin sekä automaattisen sisäisten erien eliminoinnin talouspainotteisille konserneille.","sources":[{"engine":"google_ai_mode","evidence_ref":"efc6830e-7e8e-433d-ac7d-27ad56ed31a8:google_ai_mode"},{"engine":"copilot","evidence_ref":"efc6830e-7e8e-433d-ac7d-27ad56ed31a8:copilot"}]}],"completed_answers":6,"owned_citation_rate":0},{"id":"78acafbf-61b2-4b1d-8037-ffb18dfefeb4","leader":{"is_self":false,"apex_domain":"microsoft.com","canonical_name":"Microsoft"},"engines":["chatgpt","google_ai_overviews","google_ai_mode","gemini","perplexity","copilot","claude"],"outcomes":[{"rank":null,"engine":"chatgpt","status":"absent","evidence_ref":"78acafbf-61b2-4b1d-8037-ffb18dfefeb4:chatgpt"},{"rank":null,"engine":"google_ai_overviews","status":"absent","evidence_ref":"78acafbf-61b2-4b1d-8037-ffb18dfefeb4:google_ai_overviews"},{"rank":null,"engine":"google_ai_mode","status":"absent","evidence_ref":"78acafbf-61b2-4b1d-8037-ffb18dfefeb4:google_ai_mode"},{"rank":null,"engine":"gemini","status":"absent","evidence_ref":"78acafbf-61b2-4b1d-8037-ffb18dfefeb4:gemini"},{"rank":null,"engine":"perplexity","status":"failed","evidence_ref":null},{"rank":null,"engine":"copilot","status":"absent","evidence_ref":"78acafbf-61b2-4b1d-8037-ffb18dfefeb4:copilot"},{"rank":null,"engine":"claude","status":"absent","evidence_ref":"78acafbf-61b2-4b1d-8037-ffb18dfefeb4:claude"}],"prompt_text":"Kansainvälinen suuryritystason ERP erillisillä Suomi-lokalisoinneilla vai kotimainen pilvi-ERP konsernikäytössä - mitä hyötyjä ja haittoja?","prompt_type":"comparison","share_of_voice":0,"companies_named":11,"visibility_rate":0,"consensus_answer":"Kansainväliset järjestelmät yhtenäistävät konsernin prosessit, tiedon ja raportoinnin sekä tukevat globaalia kasvua. Kotimaiset pilviratkaisut tarjoavat valmiit Suomen viranomais- ja pankkiyhteydet sekä nopean ja edullisemman käyttöönoton. Kansainvälisen ratkaisun käyttöönotto on kallis, kun taas kotimaisen vaihtoehdon skaalautuvuus ulkomaille on rajallinen.","consensus_claims":[{"text":"Kansainväliset järjestelmät yhtenäistävät konsernin prosessit, tiedon ja raportoinnin sekä tukevat globaalia kasvua.","sources":[{"engine":"chatgpt","evidence_ref":"78acafbf-61b2-4b1d-8037-ffb18dfefeb4:chatgpt"},{"engine":"gemini","evidence_ref":"78acafbf-61b2-4b1d-8037-ffb18dfefeb4:gemini"},{"engine":"copilot","evidence_ref":"78acafbf-61b2-4b1d-8037-ffb18dfefeb4:copilot"}]},{"text":"Kotimaiset pilviratkaisut tarjoavat valmiit Suomen viranomais- ja pankkiyhteydet sekä nopean ja edullisemman käyttöönoton.","sources":[{"engine":"chatgpt","evidence_ref":"78acafbf-61b2-4b1d-8037-ffb18dfefeb4:chatgpt"},{"engine":"google_ai_overviews","evidence_ref":"78acafbf-61b2-4b1d-8037-ffb18dfefeb4:google_ai_overviews"},{"engine":"google_ai_mode","evidence_ref":"78acafbf-61b2-4b1d-8037-ffb18dfefeb4:google_ai_mode"},{"engine":"copilot","evidence_ref":"78acafbf-61b2-4b1d-8037-ffb18dfefeb4:copilot"}]},{"text":"Kansainvälisen ratkaisun käyttöönotto on kallis, kun taas kotimaisen vaihtoehdon skaalautuvuus ulkomaille on rajallinen.","sources":[{"engine":"google_ai_overviews","evidence_ref":"78acafbf-61b2-4b1d-8037-ffb18dfefeb4:google_ai_overviews"},{"engine":"google_ai_mode","evidence_ref":"78acafbf-61b2-4b1d-8037-ffb18dfefeb4:google_ai_mode"},{"engine":"claude","evidence_ref":"78acafbf-61b2-4b1d-8037-ffb18dfefeb4:claude"}]}],"completed_answers":6,"owned_citation_rate":0},{"id":"27751582-975f-4641-b7fe-6b94c71aa6c8","leader":{"is_self":false,"apex_domain":"microsoft.com","canonical_name":"Microsoft"},"engines":["chatgpt","google_ai_overviews","google_ai_mode","gemini","perplexity","copilot","claude"],"outcomes":[{"rank":null,"engine":"chatgpt","status":"absent","evidence_ref":"27751582-975f-4641-b7fe-6b94c71aa6c8:chatgpt"},{"rank":null,"engine":"google_ai_overviews","status":"failed","evidence_ref":null},{"rank":null,"engine":"google_ai_mode","status":"absent","evidence_ref":"27751582-975f-4641-b7fe-6b94c71aa6c8:google_ai_mode"},{"rank":null,"engine":"gemini","status":"absent","evidence_ref":"27751582-975f-4641-b7fe-6b94c71aa6c8:gemini"},{"rank":null,"engine":"perplexity","status":"failed","evidence_ref":null},{"rank":null,"engine":"copilot","status":"absent","evidence_ref":"27751582-975f-4641-b7fe-6b94c71aa6c8:copilot"},{"rank":null,"engine":"claude","status":"absent","evidence_ref":"27751582-975f-4641-b7fe-6b94c71aa6c8:claude"}],"prompt_text":"Miten yhdistää usean tytäryhtiön erilliset talous- ja toiminnanohjausjärjestelmät kuukauden vaihteen konserniraportoinnin nopeuttamiseksi?","prompt_type":"problem","share_of_voice":0,"companies_named":9,"visibility_rate":0,"consensus_answer":"Tytäryhtiöiden omia ERP-järjestelmiä ei tarvitse korvata, vaan niiden päälle rakennetaan keskitetty raportointi- ja konsolidointiratkaisu. Paikalliset tilit ja dimensiot muunnetaan kääntötauluilla konsernin yhteiseen tilikarttaan ja standardoituun tietomalliin. Tiedonsiirto automatisoidaan rajapinnoilla, jolloin konsolidointityökalu hoitaa eliminoinnit ja valuuttamuunnokset automaattisesti.","consensus_claims":[{"text":"Tytäryhtiöiden omia ERP-järjestelmiä ei tarvitse korvata, vaan niiden päälle rakennetaan keskitetty raportointi- ja konsolidointiratkaisu.","sources":[{"engine":"chatgpt","evidence_ref":"27751582-975f-4641-b7fe-6b94c71aa6c8:chatgpt"},{"engine":"google_ai_mode","evidence_ref":"27751582-975f-4641-b7fe-6b94c71aa6c8:google_ai_mode"},{"engine":"gemini","evidence_ref":"27751582-975f-4641-b7fe-6b94c71aa6c8:gemini"},{"engine":"copilot","evidence_ref":"27751582-975f-4641-b7fe-6b94c71aa6c8:copilot"}]},{"text":"Paikalliset tilit ja dimensiot muunnetaan kääntötauluilla konsernin yhteiseen tilikarttaan ja standardoituun tietomalliin.","sources":[{"engine":"chatgpt","evidence_ref":"27751582-975f-4641-b7fe-6b94c71aa6c8:chatgpt"},{"engine":"google_ai_mode","evidence_ref":"27751582-975f-4641-b7fe-6b94c71aa6c8:google_ai_mode"},{"engine":"gemini","evidence_ref":"27751582-975f-4641-b7fe-6b94c71aa6c8:gemini"},{"engine":"claude","evidence_ref":"27751582-975f-4641-b7fe-6b94c71aa6c8:claude"}]},{"text":"Tiedonsiirto automatisoidaan rajapinnoilla, jolloin konsolidointityökalu hoitaa eliminoinnit ja valuuttamuunnokset automaattisesti.","sources":[{"engine":"chatgpt","evidence_ref":"27751582-975f-4641-b7fe-6b94c71aa6c8:chatgpt"},{"engine":"gemini","evidence_ref":"27751582-975f-4641-b7fe-6b94c71aa6c8:gemini"},{"engine":"copilot","evidence_ref":"27751582-975f-4641-b7fe-6b94c71aa6c8:copilot"}]}],"completed_answers":5,"owned_citation_rate":0}],"attributes":{"role":"Director of Enterprise IT and Business Applications","needs":["Comprehensive cloud ERP platform supporting multi-entity accounting, intercompany reconciliation, and group consolidation","High-performance REST APIs and integration connectors for enterprise software stacks","Centralized administration with granular role-based access controls for local and group finance teams"],"industry":"Conglomerates and multi-industry corporate groups","seniority":"Director","objections":["Potential operational disruption and business downtime across active subsidiaries during migration","Protracted implementation schedules competing for constrained internal technical staff","Resistance from subsidiary unit managers reluctant to abandon established local processes"],"pain_points":["Manual data compilation from disparate subsidiary systems delaying strategic executive decision-making","Fragile, custom-built integrations between legacy systems that regularly fail during reporting cycles","Inconsistent master data, inventory tracking, and chart of accounts across separate operating units"],"buying_roles":["decision_maker","technical_evaluator"],"company_size":"1,000+ employees across multiple entities","current_tools":["Disparate legacy on-premise ERP instances across operating units","Manual spreadsheet consolidation models","Custom batch data export scripts"],"buying_triggers":["Acquisition of regional subsidiaries resulting in fragmented financial and operational systems that require consolidation","Corporate mandate to decommission aging on-premise servers and standardize on unified cloud architecture","Spiraling IT overhead and maintenance costs from maintaining custom integrations across legacy software"],"generation_hint":"Base this persona on a typical buyer of 'Comprehensive cloud ERP platform' in this market from a buyer group other than: Small and micro enterprises (SMEs); Mid-sized industrial and commercial enterprises; Accounting and financial service agencies. Their role, company size and buying trigger differ from the other personas.","jobs_to_be_done":["Consolidate core financial and supply chain workflows across operating subsidiaries onto a single cloud platform","Automate Finnish statutory filings and direct bank connectivity for multiple corporate entities from one central hub","Establish standardized master data management and centralized security controls across all business units"],"desired_outcomes":["Unified operational and financial data visible in real time across all group companies","Shortened group-wide month-end closing process from weeks to days","Reduced ongoing infrastructure maintenance and legacy licensing overhead"],"responsibilities":["Formulating and executing enterprise architecture and business application roadmaps","Evaluating and selecting strategic enterprise software vendors","Directing large-scale cross-functional software migration and integration initiatives"],"success_measures":["Time required to complete group financial consolidation and monthly reporting","Percentage of group entities successfully migrated to the unified cloud platform within target milestones","Reduction in IT maintenance incidents and integration support tickets across subsidiaries"],"decision_criteria":["Depth of native Finnish regulatory compliance (OmaVero VAT, Finvoice standards, and local bank integrations) combined with multi-company management","API maturity and architecture extensibility for integrating proprietary line-of-business applications","Strength and track record of the vendor's local implementation partner ecosystem","Predictable multi-entity licensing structure and long-term total cost of ownership"],"organization_type":"private_company","alternatives_considered":["Deploying an international tier-one ERP suite with local localization add-ons","Upgrading legacy on-premise systems with custom middleware","Maintaining disparate subsidiary accounting tools and building an internal data warehouse for manual reporting"]},"description":"An enterprise IT leader at a diversified multi-entity corporate group in Finland overseeing digital modernization across multiple operating subsidiaries. Prompted by recent acquisitions and a corporate directive to eliminate disconnected legacy systems, this buyer evaluates comprehensive cloud ERP solutions that balance robust multi-company consolidation with native Finnish statutory compliance and open enterprise integration.","customer_type":"business","share_of_voice":0,"visibility_rate":0,"attribute_schema":"persona.business.v2","completed_answers":28,"owned_citation_rate":0}],"by_engine":[{"cited":0,"absent":20,"engine":"chatgpt","failed":0,"completed":20,"named_only":0},{"cited":0,"absent":18,"engine":"google_ai_overviews","failed":2,"completed":18,"named_only":0},{"cited":0,"absent":19,"engine":"google_ai_mode","failed":1,"completed":19,"named_only":0},{"cited":0,"absent":18,"engine":"gemini","failed":2,"completed":18,"named_only":0},{"cited":0,"absent":17,"engine":"perplexity","failed":3,"completed":17,"named_only":0},{"cited":0,"absent":20,"engine":"copilot","failed":0,"completed":20,"named_only":0},{"cited":0,"absent":20,"engine":"claude","failed":0,"completed":20,"named_only":0}],"report_id":"270a629c-709a-493e-9d20-2c00f8f13c37","solutions":{"detected_cms":null,"optimizer_status":"not_applicable","optimizer_compatible":false},"top_pages":{"all":{"rows":[{"url":"https://www.fikuro.fi/blogi/valmistavan-teollisuuden-erp-jarjestelmat-vertailu","path":"/blogi/valmistavan-teollisuuden-erp-jarjestelmat-vertailu","title":"ERP valmistavan teollisuuden pk-yritykselle | vertailu 2026 | Fikuro","domain":"fikuro.fi","is_owned":false,"citation_key":"f428de11055cf045","cited_answers":6,"last_cited_at":"2026-11-12T12:54:37.607300Z"},{"url":"https://procountor.fi/tilitoimistoille/ohjelmisto-tilitoimistoille","path":"/tilitoimistoille/ohjelmisto-tilitoimistoille","title":"Finago Procountor tilitoimistoille - Finago Procountor","domain":"procountor.fi","is_owned":false,"citation_key":"288233aa7ebac800","cited_answers":6,"last_cited_at":"2026-11-12T12:53:56.085687Z"},{"url":"https://procountor.fi/kirjanpito-ohjelma","path":"/kirjanpito-ohjelma","title":"Helppo kirjanpito-ohjelma pk-yrityksille | Procountor","domain":"procountor.fi","is_owned":false,"citation_key":"9c090a4f3afdc1a4","cited_answers":5,"last_cited_at":"2026-11-12T12:52:08.053721Z"},{"url":"https://www.taukokirjanpito.com/blogi/taloushallinto-ohjelma","path":"/blogi/taloushallinto-ohjelma","title":"Taloushallinto-ohjelma 2026: vertailu, moduulit ja hinnat","domain":"taukokirjanpito.com","is_owned":false,"citation_key":"cbda612b55300dd8","cited_answers":5,"last_cited_at":"2026-11-12T12:50:35.393778Z"},{"url":"https://netvisor.fi/tilitoimistoille","path":"/tilitoimistoille","title":"Taloushallinto-ohjelma tilitoimistoille | Netvisor","domain":"netvisor.fi","is_owned":false,"citation_key":"b2a76a6a0d09626d","cited_answers":4,"last_cited_at":"2026-11-12T12:53:56.085687Z"},{"url":"https://www.taukokirjanpito.com/blogi/tilitoimisto-ohjelmisto","path":"/blogi/tilitoimisto-ohjelmisto","title":"Tilitoimisto ohjelmisto 2026: vertailu ja hinnat - Tauko kirjanpito","domain":"taukokirjanpito.com","is_owned":false,"citation_key":"1c504a49529695ea","cited_answers":4,"last_cited_at":"2026-11-12T12:53:43.358296Z"},{"url":"https://yrityksen-perustaminen.net/kirjanpito-ohjelma","path":"/kirjanpito-ohjelma","title":"Paras kirjanpito-ohjelma 2026 - Yrityksen-perustaminen.net","domain":"yrityksen-perustaminen.net","is_owned":false,"citation_key":"3e65d2dda6ca1602","cited_answers":4,"last_cited_at":"2026-11-12T12:53:43.358296Z"},{"url":"https://www.fikuro.fi/blogi/erp-jarjestelmat-suomessa","path":"/blogi/erp-jarjestelmat-suomessa","title":"ERP-järjestelmät Suomessa – toiminnanohjausjärjestelmät ...","domain":"fikuro.fi","is_owned":false,"citation_key":"5b88c0cf51508b37","cited_answers":4,"last_cited_at":"2026-11-12T12:53:01.211976Z"},{"url":"https://www.erpimplementation.eu/en/erp-finland-market-guide-netvisor-procountor-heeros-finvoice-2026/","path":"/en/erp-finland-market-guide-netvisor-procountor-heeros-finvoice-2026","title":"ERP Finland 2026: Netvisor, Procountor, Heeros, Finvoice — Complete Market Guide","domain":"erpimplementation.eu","is_owned":false,"citation_key":"395c9e36504afd6b","cited_answers":4,"last_cited_at":"2026-11-12T12:52:31.982248Z"},{"url":"https://tyokaluvertailu.fi/kirjanpito/paras-taloushallinto-ohjelma","path":"/kirjanpito/paras-taloushallinto-ohjelma","title":"Taloushallinto-ohjelma 2026 | 7 ohjelmaa vertailussa","domain":"tyokaluvertailu.fi","is_owned":false,"citation_key":"c37bda39bd8a2890","cited_answers":4,"last_cited_at":"2026-11-12T12:49:37.102852Z"}],"total_sources":293},"owned":{"rows":[],"total_sources":0}},"evidence_ref":null,"generated_at":"2026-11-12T13:20:15.973454Z","leading_brands":{"rows":[{"rank":1,"is_self":false,"apex_domain":"procountor.fi","appearances":54,"canonical_name":"Procountor","visibility_rate":0.46956521739130436,"prior_visibility_rate":null,"visibility_rate_delta":null},{"rank":2,"is_self":false,"apex_domain":"netvisor.fi","appearances":48,"canonical_name":"Netvisor","visibility_rate":0.41739130434782606,"prior_visibility_rate":null,"visibility_rate_delta":null},{"rank":3,"is_self":false,"apex_domain":"microsoft.com","appearances":42,"canonical_name":"Microsoft","visibility_rate":0.3565217391304348,"prior_visibility_rate":null,"visibility_rate_delta":null},{"rank":4,"is_self":false,"apex_domain":"lemonsoft.fi","appearances":35,"canonical_name":"Lemonsoft","visibility_rate":0.30434782608695654,"prior_visibility_rate":null,"visibility_rate_delta":null},{"rank":5,"is_self":false,"apex_domain":"fennoa.fi","appearances":34,"canonical_name":"Fennoa","visibility_rate":0.2956521739130435,"prior_visibility_rate":null,"visibility_rate_delta":null},{"rank":6,"is_self":false,"apex_domain":"visma.com","appearances":32,"canonical_name":"Visma","visibility_rate":0.2782608695652174,"prior_visibility_rate":null,"visibility_rate_delta":null},{"rank":7,"is_self":false,"apex_domain":"oracle.com","appearances":21,"canonical_name":"Oracle","visibility_rate":0.1826086956521739,"prior_visibility_rate":null,"visibility_rate_delta":null},{"rank":8,"is_self":false,"apex_domain":"holvi.com","appearances":20,"canonical_name":"Holvi","visibility_rate":0.17391304347826086,"prior_visibility_rate":null,"visibility_rate_delta":null},{"rank":9,"is_self":false,"apex_domain":"sap.com","appearances":20,"canonical_name":"SAP","visibility_rate":0.17391304347826086,"prior_visibility_rate":null,"visibility_rate_delta":null},{"rank":10,"is_self":false,"apex_domain":"oscar.fi","appearances":16,"canonical_name":"Oscar Software","visibility_rate":0.1391304347826087,"prior_visibility_rate":null,"visibility_rate_delta":null}],"self":null},"schema_version":1,"company_ranking":"visibility","industry_summary":{"companies":[{"rank":1,"by_engine":[{"engine":"chatgpt","visibility_rate":0.35},{"engine":"google_ai_overviews","visibility_rate":0.4444444444444444},{"engine":"google_ai_mode","visibility_rate":0.631578947368421},{"engine":"gemini","visibility_rate":0.5},{"engine":"copilot","visibility_rate":0.4},{"engine":"claude","visibility_rate":0.5}],"prior_rank":null,"rank_delta":null,"apex_domain":"procountor.fi","appearances":54,"avg_position":1.5714285714285714,"citation_rate":0.1565217391304348,"engines_named":6,"canonical_name":"Procountor","share_of_voice":0.09540636042402827,"visibility_rate":0.46956521739130436,"prior_visibility_rate":null,"visibility_rate_delta":null},{"rank":2,"by_engine":[{"engine":"chatgpt","visibility_rate":0.4},{"engine":"google_ai_overviews","visibility_rate":0.5},{"engine":"google_ai_mode","visibility_rate":0.5789473684210527},{"engine":"gemini","visibility_rate":0.2222222222222222},{"engine":"copilot","visibility_rate":0.4},{"engine":"claude","visibility_rate":0.4}],"prior_rank":null,"rank_delta":null,"apex_domain":"netvisor.fi","appearances":48,"avg_position":1.8571428571428572,"citation_rate":0.13043478260869565,"engines_named":6,"canonical_name":"Netvisor","share_of_voice":0.08480565371024736,"visibility_rate":0.41739130434782606,"prior_visibility_rate":null,"visibility_rate_delta":null},{"rank":3,"by_engine":[{"engine":"chatgpt","visibility_rate":0.4},{"engine":"google_ai_overviews","visibility_rate":0.2777777777777778},{"engine":"google_ai_mode","visibility_rate":0.3157894736842105},{"engine":"gemini","visibility_rate":0.3333333333333333},{"engine":"copilot","visibility_rate":0.45},{"engine":"claude","visibility_rate":0.35}],"prior_rank":null,"rank_delta":null,"apex_domain":"microsoft.com","appearances":42,"avg_position":2.5555555555555554,"citation_rate":0.05217391304347826,"engines_named":6,"canonical_name":"Microsoft","share_of_voice":0.07420494699646643,"visibility_rate":0.3565217391304348,"prior_visibility_rate":null,"visibility_rate_delta":null},{"rank":4,"by_engine":[{"engine":"chatgpt","visibility_rate":0.2},{"engine":"google_ai_overviews","visibility_rate":0.3888888888888889},{"engine":"google_ai_mode","visibility_rate":0.3684210526315789},{"engine":"gemini","visibility_rate":0.3333333333333333},{"engine":"copilot","visibility_rate":0.3},{"engine":"claude","visibility_rate":0.25}],"prior_rank":null,"rank_delta":null,"apex_domain":"lemonsoft.fi","appearances":35,"avg_position":1.25,"citation_rate":0.043478260869565216,"engines_named":6,"canonical_name":"Lemonsoft","share_of_voice":0.061837455830388695,"visibility_rate":0.30434782608695654,"prior_visibility_rate":null,"visibility_rate_delta":null},{"rank":5,"by_engine":[{"engine":"chatgpt","visibility_rate":0.35},{"engine":"google_ai_overviews","visibility_rate":0.3333333333333333},{"engine":"google_ai_mode","visibility_rate":0.3684210526315789},{"engine":"gemini","visibility_rate":0.16666666666666666},{"engine":"copilot","visibility_rate":0.3},{"engine":"claude","visibility_rate":0.25}],"prior_rank":null,"rank_delta":null,"apex_domain":"fennoa.fi","appearances":34,"avg_position":2.8,"citation_rate":0,"engines_named":6,"canonical_name":"Fennoa","share_of_voice":0.06007067137809187,"visibility_rate":0.2956521739130435,"prior_visibility_rate":null,"visibility_rate_delta":null},{"rank":6,"by_engine":[{"engine":"chatgpt","visibility_rate":0.1},{"engine":"google_ai_overviews","visibility_rate":0.3333333333333333},{"engine":"google_ai_mode","visibility_rate":0.2631578947368421},{"engine":"gemini","visibility_rate":0.4444444444444444},{"engine":"copilot","visibility_rate":0.35},{"engine":"claude","visibility_rate":0.2}],"prior_rank":null,"rank_delta":null,"apex_domain":"visma.com","appearances":32,"avg_position":1.3333333333333333,"citation_rate":0,"engines_named":6,"canonical_name":"Visma","share_of_voice":0.05653710247349823,"visibility_rate":0.2782608695652174,"prior_visibility_rate":null,"visibility_rate_delta":null},{"rank":7,"by_engine":[{"engine":"chatgpt","visibility_rate":0.2},{"engine":"google_ai_overviews","visibility_rate":0.16666666666666666},{"engine":"google_ai_mode","visibility_rate":0.21052631578947367},{"engine":"gemini","visibility_rate":0.2222222222222222},{"engine":"copilot","visibility_rate":0.2},{"engine":"claude","visibility_rate":0.1}],"prior_rank":null,"rank_delta":null,"apex_domain":"oracle.com","appearances":21,"avg_position":2,"citation_rate":0.008695652173913044,"engines_named":6,"canonical_name":"Oracle","share_of_voice":0.037102473498233215,"visibility_rate":0.1826086956521739,"prior_visibility_rate":null,"visibility_rate_delta":null},{"rank":8,"by_engine":[{"engine":"chatgpt","visibility_rate":0.1},{"engine":"google_ai_overviews","visibility_rate":0.05555555555555555},{"engine":"google_ai_mode","visibility_rate":0.15789473684210525},{"engine":"gemini","visibility_rate":0.2222222222222222},{"engine":"copilot","visibility_rate":0.25},{"engine":"claude","visibility_rate":0.25}],"prior_rank":null,"rank_delta":null,"apex_domain":"holvi.com","appearances":20,"avg_position":2.6666666666666665,"citation_rate":0.017391304347826087,"engines_named":6,"canonical_name":"Holvi","share_of_voice":0.0353356890459364,"visibility_rate":0.17391304347826086,"prior_visibility_rate":null,"visibility_rate_delta":null},{"rank":9,"by_engine":[{"engine":"chatgpt","visibility_rate":0.2},{"engine":"google_ai_overviews","visibility_rate":0.1111111111111111},{"engine":"google_ai_mode","visibility_rate":0.21052631578947367},{"engine":"gemini","visibility_rate":0.1111111111111111},{"engine":"copilot","visibility_rate":0.15},{"engine":"claude","visibility_rate":0.25}],"prior_rank":null,"rank_delta":null,"apex_domain":"sap.com","appearances":20,"avg_position":3,"citation_rate":0.017391304347826087,"engines_named":6,"canonical_name":"SAP","share_of_voice":0.0353356890459364,"visibility_rate":0.17391304347826086,"prior_visibility_rate":null,"visibility_rate_delta":null},{"rank":10,"by_engine":[{"engine":"chatgpt","visibility_rate":0.15},{"engine":"google_ai_overviews","visibility_rate":0.2222222222222222},{"engine":"google_ai_mode","visibility_rate":0.15789473684210525},{"engine":"gemini","visibility_rate":0.05555555555555555},{"engine":"copilot","visibility_rate":0.15},{"engine":"claude","visibility_rate":0.1}],"prior_rank":null,"rank_delta":null,"apex_domain":"oscar.fi","appearances":16,"avg_position":3,"citation_rate":0.043478260869565216,"engines_named":6,"canonical_name":"Oscar Software","share_of_voice":0.028268551236749116,"visibility_rate":0.1391304347826087,"prior_visibility_rate":null,"visibility_rate_delta":null},{"rank":11,"by_engine":[{"engine":"chatgpt","visibility_rate":0.2},{"engine":"google_ai_overviews","visibility_rate":0.1111111111111111},{"engine":"google_ai_mode","visibility_rate":0.15789473684210525},{"engine":"gemini","visibility_rate":0.2222222222222222},{"engine":"copilot","visibility_rate":0},{"engine":"claude","visibility_rate":0.1}],"prior_rank":null,"rank_delta":null,"apex_domain":"odoo.com","appearances":15,"avg_position":4,"citation_rate":0,"engines_named":5,"canonical_name":"Odoo","share_of_voice":0.026501766784452298,"visibility_rate":0.13043478260869565,"prior_visibility_rate":null,"visibility_rate_delta":null},{"rank":12,"by_engine":[{"engine":"chatgpt","visibility_rate":0.1},{"engine":"google_ai_overviews","visibility_rate":0.16666666666666666},{"engine":"google_ai_mode","visibility_rate":0.15789473684210525},{"engine":"gemini","visibility_rate":0.1111111111111111},{"engine":"copilot","visibility_rate":0.05},{"engine":"claude","visibility_rate":0.1}],"prior_rank":null,"rank_delta":null,"apex_domain":"fivaldi.fi","appearances":13,"avg_position":null,"citation_rate":0.06086956521739131,"engines_named":6,"canonical_name":"Visma Fivaldi","share_of_voice":0.022968197879858657,"visibility_rate":0.11304347826086956,"prior_visibility_rate":null,"visibility_rate_delta":null},{"rank":13,"by_engine":[{"engine":"chatgpt","visibility_rate":0.1},{"engine":"google_ai_overviews","visibility_rate":0.2222222222222222},{"engine":"google_ai_mode","visibility_rate":0.15789473684210525},{"engine":"gemini","visibility_rate":0},{"engine":"copilot","visibility_rate":0},{"engine":"claude","visibility_rate":0.15}],"prior_rank":null,"rank_delta":null,"apex_domain":"passeli.fi","appearances":12,"avg_position":3,"citation_rate":0.017391304347826087,"engines_named":4,"canonical_name":"Passeli Merit","share_of_voice":0.02120141342756184,"visibility_rate":0.10434782608695652,"prior_visibility_rate":null,"visibility_rate_delta":null},{"rank":14,"by_engine":[{"engine":"chatgpt","visibility_rate":0.05},{"engine":"google_ai_overviews","visibility_rate":0.16666666666666666},{"engine":"google_ai_mode","visibility_rate":0.10526315789473684},{"engine":"gemini","visibility_rate":0.16666666666666666},{"engine":"copilot","visibility_rate":0.1},{"engine":"claude","visibility_rate":0.05}],"prior_rank":null,"rank_delta":null,"apex_domain":"zervant.com","appearances":12,"avg_position":1,"citation_rate":0.017391304347826087,"engines_named":6,"canonical_name":"Zervant","share_of_voice":0.02120141342756184,"visibility_rate":0.10434782608695652,"prior_visibility_rate":null,"visibility_rate_delta":null},{"rank":15,"by_engine":[{"engine":"chatgpt","visibility_rate":0.2},{"engine":"google_ai_overviews","visibility_rate":0.05555555555555555},{"engine":"google_ai_mode","visibility_rate":0.05263157894736842},{"engine":"gemini","visibility_rate":0.05555555555555555},{"engine":"copilot","visibility_rate":0.05},{"engine":"claude","visibility_rate":0.2}],"prior_rank":null,"rank_delta":null,"apex_domain":"finago.com","appearances":12,"avg_position":4,"citation_rate":0,"engines_named":6,"canonical_name":"Finago","share_of_voice":0.02120141342756184,"visibility_rate":0.10434782608695652,"prior_visibility_rate":null,"visibility_rate_delta":null},{"rank":16,"by_engine":[{"engine":"chatgpt","visibility_rate":0.15},{"engine":"google_ai_overviews","visibility_rate":0.16666666666666666},{"engine":"google_ai_mode","visibility_rate":0.10526315789473684},{"engine":"gemini","visibility_rate":0.05555555555555555},{"engine":"copilot","visibility_rate":0},{"engine":"claude","visibility_rate":0.1}],"prior_rank":null,"rank_delta":null,"apex_domain":"fikuro.fi","appearances":11,"avg_position":5,"citation_rate":0.09565217391304348,"engines_named":5,"canonical_name":"Fikuro","share_of_voice":0.019434628975265017,"visibility_rate":0.09565217391304348,"prior_visibility_rate":null,"visibility_rate_delta":null},{"rank":17,"by_engine":[{"engine":"chatgpt","visibility_rate":0},{"engine":"google_ai_overviews","visibility_rate":0.16666666666666666},{"engine":"google_ai_mode","visibility_rate":0.05263157894736842},{"engine":"gemini","visibility_rate":0.1111111111111111},{"engine":"copilot","visibility_rate":0.05},{"engine":"claude","visibility_rate":0.1}],"prior_rank":null,"rank_delta":null,"apex_domain":"heeros.com","appearances":9,"avg_position":null,"citation_rate":0.034782608695652174,"engines_named":5,"canonical_name":"Heeros","share_of_voice":0.015901060070671377,"visibility_rate":0.0782608695652174,"prior_visibility_rate":null,"visibility_rate_delta":null},{"rank":18,"by_engine":[{"engine":"chatgpt","visibility_rate":0.1},{"engine":"google_ai_overviews","visibility_rate":0},{"engine":"google_ai_mode","visibility_rate":0.05263157894736842},{"engine":"gemini","visibility_rate":0},{"engine":"copilot","visibility_rate":0.15},{"engine":"claude","visibility_rate":0.1}],"prior_rank":null,"rank_delta":null,"apex_domain":"monitorerp.com","appearances":8,"avg_position":2.5,"citation_rate":0.02608695652173913,"engines_named":4,"canonical_name":"Monitor ERP","share_of_voice":0.014134275618374558,"visibility_rate":0.06956521739130435,"prior_visibility_rate":null,"visibility_rate_delta":null},{"rank":19,"by_engine":[{"engine":"chatgpt","visibility_rate":0},{"engine":"google_ai_overviews","visibility_rate":0.1111111111111111},{"engine":"google_ai_mode","visibility_rate":0.15789473684210525},{"engine":"gemini","visibility_rate":0.1111111111111111},{"engine":"copilot","visibility_rate":0},{"engine":"claude","visibility_rate":0.05}],"prior_rank":null,"rank_delta":null,"apex_domain":"simplbooks.fi","appearances":8,"avg_position":null,"citation_rate":0,"engines_named":4,"canonical_name":"SimplBooks","share_of_voice":0.014134275618374558,"visibility_rate":0.06956521739130435,"prior_visibility_rate":null,"visibility_rate_delta":null},{"rank":20,"by_engine":[{"engine":"chatgpt","visibility_rate":0.05},{"engine":"google_ai_overviews","visibility_rate":0.16666666666666666},{"engine":"google_ai_mode","visibility_rate":0.05263157894736842},{"engine":"gemini","visibility_rate":0.05555555555555555},{"engine":"copilot","visibility_rate":0},{"engine":"claude","visibility_rate":0.05}],"prior_rank":null,"rank_delta":null,"apex_domain":"isolta.fi","appearances":7,"avg_position":3,"citation_rate":0.008695652173913044,"engines_named":5,"canonical_name":"Isolta","share_of_voice":0.012367491166077738,"visibility_rate":0.06086956521739131,"prior_visibility_rate":null,"visibility_rate_delta":null},{"rank":21,"by_engine":[{"engine":"chatgpt","visibility_rate":0.1},{"engine":"google_ai_overviews","visibility_rate":0},{"engine":"google_ai_mode","visibility_rate":0.05263157894736842},{"engine":"gemini","visibility_rate":0.05555555555555555},{"engine":"copilot","visibility_rate":0.1},{"engine":"claude","visibility_rate":0.05}],"prior_rank":null,"rank_delta":null,"apex_domain":"ifs.com","appearances":7,"avg_position":4,"citation_rate":0,"engines_named":5,"canonical_name":"IFS","share_of_voice":0.012367491166077738,"visibility_rate":0.06086956521739131,"prior_visibility_rate":null,"visibility_rate_delta":null},{"rank":22,"by_engine":[{"engine":"chatgpt","visibility_rate":0.05},{"engine":"google_ai_overviews","visibility_rate":0},{"engine":"google_ai_mode","visibility_rate":0.10526315789473684},{"engine":"gemini","visibility_rate":0.05555555555555555},{"engine":"copilot","visibility_rate":0},{"engine":"claude","visibility_rate":0.15}],"prior_rank":null,"rank_delta":null,"apex_domain":"kitsas.fi","appearances":7,"avg_position":4,"citation_rate":0,"engines_named":4,"canonical_name":"Kitsas","share_of_voice":0.012367491166077738,"visibility_rate":0.06086956521739131,"prior_visibility_rate":null,"visibility_rate_delta":null},{"rank":23,"by_engine":[{"engine":"chatgpt","visibility_rate":0},{"engine":"google_ai_overviews","visibility_rate":0.1111111111111111},{"engine":"google_ai_mode","visibility_rate":0.05263157894736842},{"engine":"gemini","visibility_rate":0.05555555555555555},{"engine":"copilot","visibility_rate":0},{"engine":"claude","visibility_rate":0.1}],"prior_rank":null,"rank_delta":null,"apex_domain":"emce.fi","appearances":6,"avg_position":null,"citation_rate":0.02608695652173913,"engines_named":4,"canonical_name":"EmCe","share_of_voice":0.01060070671378092,"visibility_rate":0.05217391304347826,"prior_visibility_rate":null,"visibility_rate_delta":null},{"rank":24,"by_engine":[{"engine":"chatgpt","visibility_rate":0.05},{"engine":"google_ai_overviews","visibility_rate":0.1111111111111111},{"engine":"google_ai_mode","visibility_rate":0.05263157894736842},{"engine":"gemini","visibility_rate":0.1111111111111111},{"engine":"copilot","visibility_rate":0},{"engine":"claude","visibility_rate":0}],"prior_rank":null,"rank_delta":null,"apex_domain":"xledger.com","appearances":6,"avg_position":null,"citation_rate":0.02608695652173913,"engines_named":4,"canonical_name":"Xledger","share_of_voice":0.01060070671378092,"visibility_rate":0.05217391304347826,"prior_visibility_rate":null,"visibility_rate_delta":null},{"rank":25,"by_engine":[{"engine":"chatgpt","visibility_rate":0.1},{"engine":"google_ai_overviews","visibility_rate":0.05555555555555555},{"engine":"google_ai_mode","visibility_rate":0},{"engine":"gemini","visibility_rate":0},{"engine":"copilot","visibility_rate":0},{"engine":"claude","visibility_rate":0.1}],"prior_rank":null,"rank_delta":null,"apex_domain":"tietosuunta.com","appearances":5,"avg_position":null,"citation_rate":0.06956521739130435,"engines_named":3,"canonical_name":"Tietosuunta","share_of_voice":0.0088339222614841,"visibility_rate":0.043478260869565216,"prior_visibility_rate":null,"visibility_rate_delta":null},{"rank":26,"by_engine":[{"engine":"chatgpt","visibility_rate":0.05},{"engine":"google_ai_overviews","visibility_rate":0},{"engine":"google_ai_mode","visibility_rate":0.05263157894736842},{"engine":"gemini","visibility_rate":0.05555555555555555},{"engine":"copilot","visibility_rate":0},{"engine":"claude","visibility_rate":0.1}],"prior_rank":null,"rank_delta":null,"apex_domain":"laskuhari.fi","appearances":5,"avg_position":2,"citation_rate":0.008695652173913044,"engines_named":4,"canonical_name":"Laskuhari","share_of_voice":0.0088339222614841,"visibility_rate":0.043478260869565216,"prior_visibility_rate":null,"visibility_rate_delta":null},{"rank":27,"by_engine":[{"engine":"chatgpt","visibility_rate":0},{"engine":"google_ai_overviews","visibility_rate":0.05555555555555555},{"engine":"google_ai_mode","visibility_rate":0.10526315789473684},{"engine":"gemini","visibility_rate":0},{"engine":"copilot","visibility_rate":0.1},{"engine":"claude","visibility_rate":0}],"prior_rank":null,"rank_delta":null,"apex_domain":"ukko.fi","appearances":5,"avg_position":1,"citation_rate":0.008695652173913044,"engines_named":3,"canonical_name":"Ukko Yrittäjä","share_of_voice":0.0088339222614841,"visibility_rate":0.043478260869565216,"prior_visibility_rate":null,"visibility_rate_delta":null},{"rank":28,"by_engine":[{"engine":"chatgpt","visibility_rate":0.1},{"engine":"google_ai_overviews","visibility_rate":0.05555555555555555},{"engine":"google_ai_mode","visibility_rate":0.05263157894736842},{"engine":"gemini","visibility_rate":0},{"engine":"copilot","visibility_rate":0},{"engine":"claude","visibility_rate":0.05}],"prior_rank":null,"rank_delta":null,"apex_domain":"netbaron.fi","appearances":5,"avg_position":null,"citation_rate":0,"engines_named":4,"canonical_name":"Confirma NetBaron","share_of_voice":0.0088339222614841,"visibility_rate":0.043478260869565216,"prior_visibility_rate":null,"visibility_rate_delta":null},{"rank":29,"by_engine":[{"engine":"chatgpt","visibility_rate":0},{"engine":"google_ai_overviews","visibility_rate":0.05555555555555555},{"engine":"google_ai_mode","visibility_rate":0.05263157894736842},{"engine":"gemini","visibility_rate":0.05555555555555555},{"engine":"copilot","visibility_rate":0},{"engine":"claude","visibility_rate":0.05}],"prior_rank":null,"rank_delta":null,"apex_domain":"etasku.fi","appearances":4,"avg_position":null,"citation_rate":0.008695652173913044,"engines_named":4,"canonical_name":"eTasku","share_of_voice":0.007067137809187279,"visibility_rate":0.034782608695652174,"prior_visibility_rate":null,"visibility_rate_delta":null},{"rank":30,"by_engine":[{"engine":"chatgpt","visibility_rate":0.05},{"engine":"google_ai_overviews","visibility_rate":0.05555555555555555},{"engine":"google_ai_mode","visibility_rate":0.05263157894736842},{"engine":"gemini","visibility_rate":0},{"engine":"copilot","visibility_rate":0.05},{"engine":"claude","visibility_rate":0}],"prior_rank":null,"rank_delta":null,"apex_domain":"unit4.com","appearances":4,"avg_position":3,"citation_rate":0.008695652173913044,"engines_named":4,"canonical_name":"Unit4","share_of_voice":0.007067137809187279,"visibility_rate":0.034782608695652174,"prior_visibility_rate":null,"visibility_rate_delta":null}],"by_persona":[{"persona_id":"0a10f26a-16cb-43a4-b930-3477c3446bb5","top_companies":[{"apex_domain":"procountor.fi","canonical_name":"Procountor","visibility_rate":0.8},{"apex_domain":"holvi.com","canonical_name":"Holvi","visibility_rate":0.6333333333333333},{"apex_domain":"netvisor.fi","canonical_name":"Netvisor","visibility_rate":0.5333333333333333}],"leading_visibility":[{"apex_domain":"procountor.fi","canonical_name":"Procountor","visibility_rate":0.8},{"apex_domain":"netvisor.fi","canonical_name":"Netvisor","visibility_rate":0.5333333333333333},{"apex_domain":"microsoft.com","canonical_name":"Microsoft","visibility_rate":0},{"apex_domain":"lemonsoft.fi","canonical_name":"Lemonsoft","visibility_rate":0.03333333333333333},{"apex_domain":"fennoa.fi","canonical_name":"Fennoa","visibility_rate":0.26666666666666666},{"apex_domain":"visma.com","canonical_name":"Visma","visibility_rate":0.06666666666666667},{"apex_domain":"oracle.com","canonical_name":"Oracle","visibility_rate":0},{"apex_domain":"holvi.com","canonical_name":"Holvi","visibility_rate":0.6333333333333333},{"apex_domain":"sap.com","canonical_name":"SAP","visibility_rate":0},{"apex_domain":"oscar.fi","canonical_name":"Oscar Software","visibility_rate":0}],"answers_naming_a_company":0.9666666666666667},{"persona_id":"cef03561-c7f6-413d-86d3-80ec981f8dd0","top_companies":[{"apex_domain":"lemonsoft.fi","canonical_name":"Lemonsoft","visibility_rate":0.6896551724137931},{"apex_domain":"microsoft.com","canonical_name":"Microsoft","visibility_rate":0.5172413793103449},{"apex_domain":"visma.com","canonical_name":"Visma","visibility_rate":0.4482758620689655}],"leading_visibility":[{"apex_domain":"procountor.fi","canonical_name":"Procountor","visibility_rate":0.1724137931034483},{"apex_domain":"netvisor.fi","canonical_name":"Netvisor","visibility_rate":0.20689655172413793},{"apex_domain":"microsoft.com","canonical_name":"Microsoft","visibility_rate":0.5172413793103449},{"apex_domain":"lemonsoft.fi","canonical_name":"Lemonsoft","visibility_rate":0.6896551724137931},{"apex_domain":"fennoa.fi","canonical_name":"Fennoa","visibility_rate":0.10344827586206896},{"apex_domain":"visma.com","canonical_name":"Visma","visibility_rate":0.4482758620689655},{"apex_domain":"oracle.com","canonical_name":"Oracle","visibility_rate":0.034482758620689655},{"apex_domain":"holvi.com","canonical_name":"Holvi","visibility_rate":0},{"apex_domain":"sap.com","canonical_name":"SAP","visibility_rate":0.034482758620689655},{"apex_domain":"oscar.fi","canonical_name":"Oscar Software","visibility_rate":0.41379310344827586}],"answers_naming_a_company":0.8275862068965517},{"persona_id":"854f4c50-d340-44bf-87d8-aed893bd5bd3","top_companies":[{"apex_domain":"fennoa.fi","canonical_name":"Fennoa","visibility_rate":0.75},{"apex_domain":"procountor.fi","canonical_name":"Procountor","visibility_rate":0.7142857142857143},{"apex_domain":"netvisor.fi","canonical_name":"Netvisor","visibility_rate":0.6785714285714286}],"leading_visibility":[{"apex_domain":"procountor.fi","canonical_name":"Procountor","visibility_rate":0.7142857142857143},{"apex_domain":"netvisor.fi","canonical_name":"Netvisor","visibility_rate":0.6785714285714286},{"apex_domain":"microsoft.com","canonical_name":"Microsoft","visibility_rate":0},{"apex_domain":"lemonsoft.fi","canonical_name":"Lemonsoft","visibility_rate":0.10714285714285714},{"apex_domain":"fennoa.fi","canonical_name":"Fennoa","visibility_rate":0.75},{"apex_domain":"visma.com","canonical_name":"Visma","visibility_rate":0.14285714285714285},{"apex_domain":"oracle.com","canonical_name":"Oracle","visibility_rate":0},{"apex_domain":"holvi.com","canonical_name":"Holvi","visibility_rate":0.03571428571428571},{"apex_domain":"sap.com","canonical_name":"SAP","visibility_rate":0},{"apex_domain":"oscar.fi","canonical_name":"Oscar Software","visibility_rate":0}],"answers_naming_a_company":0.8571428571428571},{"persona_id":"a98ff54d-c194-4f84-b493-b6b8f2b855ba","top_companies":[{"apex_domain":"microsoft.com","canonical_name":"Microsoft","visibility_rate":0.9285714285714286},{"apex_domain":"oracle.com","canonical_name":"Oracle","visibility_rate":0.7142857142857143},{"apex_domain":"sap.com","canonical_name":"SAP","visibility_rate":0.6785714285714286}],"leading_visibility":[{"apex_domain":"procountor.fi","canonical_name":"Procountor","visibility_rate":0.17857142857142858},{"apex_domain":"netvisor.fi","canonical_name":"Netvisor","visibility_rate":0.25},{"apex_domain":"microsoft.com","canonical_name":"Microsoft","visibility_rate":0.9285714285714286},{"apex_domain":"lemonsoft.fi","canonical_name":"Lemonsoft","visibility_rate":0.39285714285714285},{"apex_domain":"fennoa.fi","canonical_name":"Fennoa","visibility_rate":0.07142857142857142},{"apex_domain":"visma.com","canonical_name":"Visma","visibility_rate":0.4642857142857143},{"apex_domain":"oracle.com","canonical_name":"Oracle","visibility_rate":0.7142857142857143},{"apex_domain":"holvi.com","canonical_name":"Holvi","visibility_rate":0},{"apex_domain":"sap.com","canonical_name":"SAP","visibility_rate":0.6785714285714286},{"apex_domain":"oscar.fi","canonical_name":"Oscar Software","visibility_rate":0.14285714285714285}],"answers_naming_a_company":0.9642857142857143}],"cited_domains":[{"share":0.1565217391304348,"domain":"procountor.fi","company":"Procountor","cited_answers":18},{"share":0.1565217391304348,"domain":"taukokirjanpito.com","company":null,"cited_answers":18},{"share":0.13043478260869565,"domain":"netvisor.fi","company":"Netvisor","cited_answers":15},{"share":0.13043478260869565,"domain":"tyokaluvertailu.fi","company":null,"cited_answers":15},{"share":0.09565217391304348,"domain":"fikuro.fi","company":"Fikuro","cited_answers":11},{"share":0.0782608695652174,"domain":"fennoa.com","company":null,"cited_answers":9},{"share":0.06956521739130435,"domain":"tietosuunta.com","company":"Tietosuunta","cited_answers":8},{"share":0.06086956521739131,"domain":"fivaldi.fi","company":"Visma Fivaldi","cited_answers":7},{"share":0.05217391304347826,"domain":"microsoft.com","company":"Microsoft","cited_answers":6},{"share":0.05217391304347826,"domain":"yrityksen-perustaminen.net","company":null,"cited_answers":6}],"citation_split":{"third_party":248,"company_sites":133},"companies_named":80,"top3_share_of_voice":{"delta":null,"prior":null,"current":0.254416961130742,"prior_numerator":null,"current_numerator":144,"prior_denominator":null,"current_denominator":566},"companies_per_answer":4.913043478260869,"named_by_every_engine":13,"answers_naming_a_company":{"delta":null,"prior":null,"current":0.9043478260869565,"prior_numerator":null,"current_numerator":104,"prior_denominator":null,"current_denominator":115},"companies_for_half_of_mentions":8},"executive_summary":"With mentions in 47% of AI answers, Procountor is this study's most-mentioned company. AI Mode mentions Procountor more often than ChatGPT. The answers span 80 companies, with 8 accounting for at least half of all company mentions. Procountor is most visible for the customer profile \"Finnish micro-entrepreneurs and sole traders\", appearing in 80% of those answers. The most frequently cited sources are procountor.fi and taukokirjanpito.com. 13 companies appear in answers from every measured assistant. At least 34% of recorded source links point to websites of companies named in this study."}}